News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Do Not Negotiate with Terrorists by patio11 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @04:26PM (#6857377)
As a counterpoint: I have the opposite policy for refunds, and have for the last 8ish years. The official version, to satisfy my accountant [+], is a full refund with no questions asked for 30 to 60 days. The unofficial version is that I will give anyone a refund in (basically) perpetuity. I think my current record is 70 months after the transaction.

My refund rate for BCC is 2.7%. That's the easiest one for me to calculate with a single SQL query. Don't hold me to these, but I think AR and my other products are at about 1% and 0.5%.

Refunds are a very easy way to amicably part ways with ex-customers who are not good fits for you, rather than having the resolution where a) they can't use your software and b) they feel like you've stolen their money.

Refunds quickly remove problem customers from your inbox. This will save you time and, more preciously, sanity.

Prominent money-back guarantees frequently increase sales in a statistically significant fashion across your entire company. This is one of the cheapest A/B tests to implement, by the way, since you can create a guarantee by adding two sentences of copy.

Most customers have a fully functional put option on your digital goods, brokered by their credit card company and assignable to you instantly by saying the words "Internet merchant" and "chargeback." You should prefer that customers resolve disputes amicably, via refunds, rather than aggressively, via chargebacks. Chargebacks come with aggressive fees ($15 to $25 plus the purchase) and accumulating too many of them can get your merchant privileges revoked. (This is about the point in the post where somebody is going to suggest adopting Alpha Black Lotus Depository Certificates, which they believe to be superior to credit cards because ABLDCs don't have chargebacks. This is a moot point because your customers don't possess ABLDCs, but be that as it may, charebacks are net welfare enhancing for merchants because, like generous refund policies, they encourage transactions.)

Refunds will not typically meaningfully impact your cash flow in a digital goods business. You probably have stupendously high margins -- they absorb refunds as a cost of doing business quite easily. You can implement a rolling reserve on yourself [++] to cover them -- mine is $500, which is more than adequate at a revenue figure in the six figures.

+ Your accountant may not be happy if you sell goods with perpetual characteristics because it makes revenue recognition more complicated than it needs to be.

++ Rolling reserve = "Don't spend the last $500 in the checking account", which is good advice for a host of reasons, not the least of which being you'll never worry about refunds impacting cash flow.

Re:We Do Not Negotiate with Terrorists by BryanB55 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @04:40PM (#6857473)
Agreed. We do the same and sell digital products. Not happy? No questions, no hassles, 100% refund. Hardly anyone asks for a refund. In fact, I'd say its less than 2% but I don't have an easy way to calculate it unfortunately. In most cases we try to work with people to fix any issues and after an email or two everything is fine. But we occasionally do get the "pathological customers" that patio11 likes to talk about. In those cases having the ability to give a refund is really nice because it is an easy way to part ways and "fire" customers you don't want to work with.

I think a lot of people are initially afraid to offer refunds, most notably for digital products. The ones I've talked to always say "but then they can just ask for a refund and get it for free!" Sure... they could, but, hardly anyone ever does from my experience. My advice would be to at least give it a try and see how it works, you might find out that it is actually an effective marketing tool and a way to gain trust while lowering the perceived risk for new customers.

Re:We Do Not Negotiate with Terrorists by spinlock on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:07PM (#6857664)
I have the same refund policy specifically for chargebacks. Here's a fun side note: despite the fact that I always issue a full refund, I had one customer chargeback a purchase. I decided to contest the chargeback and, amazingly, I won. I still don't know how that ended up in my favor but I feel like I just saw a unicorn and wanted to share.
Re:We Do Not Negotiate with Terrorists by patio11 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:15PM (#6857718)
Here's my unicorn: CEO Bob buys the service, uses it happily for 6 months. Bookkeeper Cindy wonders what this strange recurring bill could possibly be, assumes it is credit card fraud, and initiates six chargebacks. I get on phone. Bob brings Cindy on call, explains the situation, and tells Cindy to call bank and cancel chargeback. We document the conversation over an email, which I file with my credit card processor.

I still lost.

Re:We Do Not Negotiate with Terrorists by spinlock on Thursday December 12, 2013 @06:17PM (#6897970)
I think our files must have gotten switched at the credit card company. What I don't understand is why Cindy didn't remove the chargeback. That should settle things for you, right?
Re:We Do Not Negotiate with Terrorists by marshally on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:35PM (#6857881)
Refunded license for Ignition Deck: $299

Transaction fees associated with refund: a few dollars

Making an ass of yourself in public? Priceless!

Re:We Do Not Negotiate with Terrorists by networked on Thursday December 05, 2013 @04:32PM (#6857410)
>I think my current record is 70 months after the transaction.

If you are comfortable sharing it I would love to hear the story behind that.

Re:We Do Not Negotiate with Terrorists by patio11 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @04:38PM (#6857454)
>> I bought a Mac in 1998. I bought Bingo Card Creator in 2007. My Mac broke and I lost my hard drive. I bought a new Mac, but Bingo Card Creator doesn't work on it. I can't use the online version because I'm on dialup that gets charged by the minute. I want my money back.

Signed, Surprisingly Common @ AOL.com

>> Sorry to hear that. Apple changed something in 2010 or so, which makes it impossible to use the downloadable version of Bingo Card Creator on newer Macs. We unfortunately can't fix that on our end. I understand that you can't use the online version, which works on Macs and PCs. Thanks for using Bingo Card Creator for so many years, though. Tell you what, tell me your address and I'll write you a check.

Re:We Do Not Negotiate with Terrorists by ufmace on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:24PM (#6857804)
What does a refund look like on AR, or any other recurring SaaS product, anyway? If somebody has been using it for, say, 6 months, then decides they don't want it anymore and asks for a refund, what do you refund? The most recent month? All 6 months?
Re:We Do Not Negotiate with Terrorists by patio11 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @05:32PM (#6857861)
Officially, any payments you made in the last 30 days. Unofficially, if you tell me "Gadzooks I got billed for this for 6 months because I never canceled my free trial and missed the 6 invoices you sent me", I'll reverse 2-3 charges (I lose the capability to do so something like 60 days after the transaction) and then tell you that you have options for the remaining months: a) I write a check to charity, b) I write a check to you, c) you let me keep it. Pick whichever sounds fair.

$174 is, literally, less than rounding error.

I am aware of other companies which hew more closely to "Just your last payment", and even one prominent SaaS company with a declared no-refunds policy, but they don't strike me as being material improvements.

Re:We Do Not Negotiate with Terrorists by tieTYT on Thursday December 05, 2013 @04:36PM (#6857443)
Do you offer money back guarantees for the consulting you provide, too? Or does this advice only apply to products?
Re:We Do Not Negotiate with Terrorists by patio11 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @04:56PM (#6857575)
I was occasionally asked for that. My response was typically along the lines of "The model for consulting is typically that I'm guaranteed my rate and you're guaranteed all of the upside. If you want me to take on the downside risk for this project, I would want to share equitably in the upside. My sense of equitable is that if I double your sales I end up owning half of the company."

That typically achieved the laugh I was going for. But seriously, if my contracts included a no-fault do-not-pay-Patrick option, my rates would be positively Rumpelstiltskinian to compensate.

There's many ways to de-risk potential offerings. Back when I was consulting, a money-back guarantee was not one which I needed to fill my engagement calendar. Customer references, a bit of a brand name, case studies, and a history of doing pretty much exactly what I get paid to do in a pretty public fashion mostly sufficed.

I can also very easily think of situations where that would have been personally catastrophic to me without any fault of my own (e.g. six months down the line client X exits line of business I consulted on, triggers guarantee on our $50k contract after I've already used that money to pay for my wedding). That strikes me as not a great idea, at all.

Re:We Do Not Negotiate with Terrorists by JonMatthews on Friday December 06, 2013 @06:59AM (#6860637)
Wow - Patrick, I assume that £500 isn't your entire reserve, just the one for refunds? Natural variability in sales would make that a game of financial russian roulette!
Re:We Do Not Negotiate with Terrorists by patio11 on Friday December 06, 2013 @09:47AM (#6861250)
I honestly do way, way too much cash flow juggling and should just bite the bullet and build up a larger cushion than I have, but you're right, both in the "that isn't the typical cash-on-hand" and "if it were, that would be crazily risky."