Re:The Libertarian Case for a Basic Income
by yummyfajitas on Thursday December 05, 2013 @01:41PM
(#6856216)
Could you explain how to have both a welfare state and a lot more immigration? How do you make the numbers work?
Re:The Libertarian Case for a Basic Income
by nawitus on Thursday December 05, 2013 @01:43PM
(#6856238)
A lot more than what? One can have welfare state and a degree of immigration. Usually more immigration means that it's more expensive. Sweden has considerable immigration when compared to many other countries, and is also a welfare state. Immigration doesn't mean open borders.
Re:The Libertarian Case for a Basic Income
by yummyfajitas on Thursday December 05, 2013 @01:54PM
(#6856315)
For humanitarian reasons, it's important to get as close to open borders as we can. What benefits of a first world welfare state do we gain that are worth consigning a human being to live on $1300/year (the GDP/capita of Haiti)?
Sweden is a pretty terrible example to cite. Go read the blog of Tino Sanandaji (an Iraqi immigrant to Sweden) - he does a great job showing why it's a failed policy and prevents some of the best arguments against immigration that I've read.
No. There are countries that have comprehensive social security and have immigration resembling what we have today - e.g. these countries have immigration that they already have.