News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Was Cantor Wrong? Are the real numbers countable? by dmfdmf on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @11:07PM (#6852631)
>... at least on my terms

This was not a cop out as you portray but recognition that many people are not familiar with Aristole's position on infinity nor is it the popular view. I defined my terms and explained my position as to why Cantor's use of "completed infinity" is a contradiction. It is clear to anyone who wants to understand. I defy you to define, in your own words, your concept of infinity and what you actually mean by a completed one without degenerating into non-sense.

> The philosophy of mathematics has considered this matter settled for several hundred years now.

This was hardly a fair fight. As I conceded, the mystics won round one which is why Cantor's non-sense is accepted. The philosophy of mathematics is and was dominated by Platonists and other avowed irrationalists. So no surprise in this outcome.

There are no comments on this comment yet.