News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Has StackOverflow saved billions of dollars in programmer... by InclinedPlane on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @06:25PM (#6851297)
Personally I think StackOverflow is pretty good. It's always nice to see it popup in search results when googling for a technical problem, for example. My main complaint is that they've been resting on their laurels for quite a while, there's a lot of potential that's been wasted with SO/SE.
Re:Has StackOverflow saved billions of dollars in programmer... by sklivvz1971 on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @06:41PM (#6851416)
(*) where resting on laurels is defined as launching 111 sites running on 9 web servers with traffic doubling every 12 months while writing two native mobile apps and localizing the site :-)
Re:Has StackOverflow saved billions of dollars in programmer... by InclinedPlane on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @06:59PM (#6851544)
Hey, that's great, but to be brutally honest most of those sites are borderline inconsequential. The fact that SE has yet to launch a site that's gotten bigger than StackOverflow is pretty damning. Everything else you describe is just work, it's not innovation.
Re:Has StackOverflow saved billions of dollars in programmer... by spolsky on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @07:14PM (#6851635)
Re:Has StackOverflow saved billions of dollars in programmer... by InclinedPlane on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @07:47PM (#6851807)
That's good but SE is a federation of sites, so it's an unfair comparison.

From the start I've always thought that the biggest danger to SO/SE wasn't failure, you guys are smart enough to see and recover from outright failure. Instead it's reaching a level of success far below what you're capable of.

It seems to me that SO/SE spent a lot of work innovating in the early days but once they found their comfort zone they've stopped innovating. They are good sites for their intended purpose but how much of the original vision has been abandoned? I remember back when you and Jeff were talking about taking over the way all online discussion happened. Nothing like that is even remotely possible with the way StackExchange is today.

To be bluntly honest I think you guys are just lucky that most of the ambitious and competent folks in the industry don't view discussion as "sexy" so you don't have as much ompetition as you would otherwise (quora is practically a joke). But realistically it's just a matter of time until SE will be out innovated.

Re:Has StackOverflow saved billions of dollars in programmer... by teh_klev on Thursday December 05, 2013 @01:18PM (#6856025)
"I remember back when you and Jeff were talking about taking over the way all online discussion happened." - not quite right. The problem in hand was that good Q&A was buried in discussion forum type apps.

The whole point of SO from the beginning was to build a Q&A site for programmers that didn't suffer from the shortcomings of using apps such as phpBB etc, where threads get hijacked and pages upon pages of extraneous discussion and arguments take place making it difficult to find and answer to a specific problem.

Re:Has StackOverflow saved billions of dollars in programmer... by lelandbatey on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:33PM (#6852310)
I'm not totally sure about that, if for the sole reason that SO/SE has such a huge volume of answered questions already. Unless they make those answers harder to access, I think there will always be a contingent of people who'll need them.

However, I do hope that we get an even better discussion platform than the ones we have now. I really look forward to even cooler products in the future.

Re:Has StackOverflow saved billions of dollars in programmer... by termain on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @11:30PM (#6852710)
"I remember back when you and Jeff were talking about taking over the way all online discussion happened."

Aren't they now -- or at least Jeff Atwood -- working on Discourse?

Re:Has StackOverflow saved billions of dollars in programmer... by voltagex_ on Thursday December 05, 2013 @01:59AM (#6853055)
Yep, discourse.org. It's a little too heavy weight for my uses and I think they really need to get the client and server requirements down a bit so that it can take over where PHPBB was once used.

See http://discuss.emberjs.com/ and http://bbs.boingboing.net/ for real world implementations. It's very, very cool to see forums being dragged out of the 1990s.

Re:Has StackOverflow saved billions of dollars in programmer... by InclinedPlane on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:45AM (#6853911)
Jeff left StackExchange, he's just working on his own now.
Re:Has StackOverflow saved billions of dollars in programmer... by jc4p on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @07:33PM (#6851730)
True and Stack Overflow is #1 in North Korea.
Re:Has StackOverflow saved billions of dollars in programmer... by jc4p on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @06:31PM (#6851359)
Just curious, what do you think we could be doing that we aren't?

Also thanks for teaching me a new idiom :)

Re:Has StackOverflow saved billions of dollars in programmer... by InclinedPlane on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @07:04PM (#6851570)
In general, experimenting more. You've tackled the narrow use case of a single question with answers, but is that all SE can be, or should be? The thing that I think SE is most lacking is better ways to tackle the sheer amount of data on the site. There's a lot of information there but in general it's not very well organized. Go back to the original announcements about the launch of SO and see what it was supposed to be and how it has either lived up or not to those ideas.

Try this thought experiment: if a stack exchange competitor showed up tomorrow, what sorts of features would it have to have to make you start waking up in a cold sweat every day?

Re:Has StackOverflow saved billions of dollars in programmer... by jc4p on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @07:36PM (#6851758)
Luckily a lot of us are on the same page as you :)

One of the things I consider a main detriment of our current product is that for the vast majority of users it's built to be transactional. Search, land on SO, read, go back to work.

On our currently in development mobile apps we're trying out something different, for the first time at scale we're pushing content to users rather than having them search for it as the number one utility of the product. The apps have a "Feed" which is machine learned interesting for you questions.

I love it since I search SO at work but when I get home or am walking around town I can open my app and instantly lose 30 mins (at least) to reading and interacting with very interesting content. I can't wait to see if others like it.

Re:Has StackOverflow saved billions of dollars in programmer... by startuup on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @08:59PM (#6852154)
Thats a great start but there are other ideas too. Why isn't SE as useful for people in other professions, like product managers or data scientists or marketers who are also looking for answers to their work problems? The key is that just replicating the site is not the answer, you need to really focus on community dev and getting the thought leaders from those professionals involved. Lastly, along with the 'feed' implementation, you can also start curating other content from the web that could be useful to the users of your site. example: If I am particularly interested in Javascript, I get a feed of curated resources from around the web that will help me learn about the latest and greatest in Javacript. Thats whats missing today and thats why SO is a transactional site
Re:Has StackOverflow saved billions of dollars in programmer... by jc4p on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @09:36PM (#6852319)
I actually originally had something related in my post but removed it: I won't personally consider the site I work on a success unless my mom uses it. She's a physics PhD and she once in a while stumbles onto physics.SE when searching online but she doesn't actually use the site.

I think SO and Server Fault are the size they are because they have an intrinsic advantage over our other sites. People in the target audience work and live in the same tech ecosystem as a website, with something like physics that's an initial burden.

SE itself also has a high barrier to entry. Every one of our sites has it's own rules and definition of what type of content is acceptable. This is for a very good reason, seeking out absolute answers to questions. Most other websites on the internet live to foster discussion, but we're not a forum.

Making stack exchange a common name (in more than our sizable niche) is one of our company goals, but I don't really know what we can do to get past the initial issue I mentioned and reducing the second would hurt our product.

It's quite an interesting idea to be more proactive about bringing thought leaders to out lesser known sites, I don't know if we could do it just directly since most thought leaders are very busy people who already have a dozen places people ask them questions but it's something to think about. We already consider expertise of contributors in Area 51, our incubator for new website ideas.

Perhaps while we may not be able to get the top 1% of thought leaders onto our websites without giving them a really hard question to answer (my mom loves difficult questions, god knows how many times she used to run into my room and say she solved a question I asked her in passing days prior) but it might be possible to bring in up-and-coming thought leaders. A lot of my friends from the health and fitness industry (were I used to live) might want to use our Physical Fitness Stack Exchange site to foster their own personal brand.

Re:Has StackOverflow saved billions of dollars in programmer... by startuup on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @10:23PM (#6852496)
I can understand that being an absolute answers to questions makes sense for some of the technical fields where the answers are black and white. However, as you start branching out to other forms of questions, like your mom's who is a PHD in physics, sometimes the answers are not absolute, but its the discussion around them that unearths something really powerful. So, why not test that out in one of your websites? Whats the worse that can happen? You can change it back.

To your initial issue, yes reaching out to the upcoming thought leaders could be great. I know of a few friends in fitness industry who send me thoughts via email. But don't discount the ability for you to get the top 1% thought leaders. Have you tried it? You would be surprised by how many of them actually want to show their leadership and 'help' others.

BTW Thanks for reading my answer. I usually am a silent browser of HN and felt compelled to answer since I have been thinking about this a lot. Would be happy to jump on skype to chat further.

Re:Has StackOverflow saved billions of dollars in programmer... by jiggy2011 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @02:10AM (#6853076)
I guess programming is particularly fast moving and information becomes obsolete very quickly. A book about mobile app development written in 2005 would be laughably obsolete today. A mechanical engineer on the other hand can probably still find value in books written in the 1960s.

So there's less need to be constantly feeling out new undocumented territory in other professions.

Re:Has StackOverflow saved billions of dollars in programmer... by CJefferson on Thursday December 05, 2013 @03:28AM (#6853239)
My main with stack overflow, as it gets older, is answer rot. A couple of times I have come across answers which have become out of date, but it is non obvious to me the best way to reopen the question (I, along with most readers don't have the karma to edit questions / answers )
Re:Has StackOverflow saved billions of dollars in programmer... by pjbrunet on Thursday December 05, 2013 @03:50AM (#6853300)
Maybe write a comment, "This is out of date. Can someone update this?" You might even want to flag the question. You can also add a new answer and downvote the obsolete answer. Getting enough points to edit questions is pretty easy.
Re:Has StackOverflow saved billions of dollars in programmer... by sklivvz1971 on Thursday December 05, 2013 @07:35AM (#6854075)
Everyone can edit questions and answers (if you don't have the full-on privilege yet, your edit will go in a queue and be vetted by more experienced users).