News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dean Says Median Grade at Harvard College Is A-, Most Com... by jjoonathan on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @04:50PM (#6850531)
How did this:

> variation in difficulty between classes, professors, and peer-groups can easily dominate variation in difficulty imposed by the grading scale

Become this:

> 4.0 GPA CC < 2.0 GPA Harvard. This implies: 2.0 GPA CC < 2.0 GPA Harvard. Now we drop 2.0 GPA from both sides and we get CC < Harvard, or Harvard > CC. ... Harvard is so 1337, there's no way that Harvard < CC, right (in some cases)?

And why do you think I'm performing a cost/benefit analysis? I relayed an anecdote about a single class that had to do with course material, not finances or overall GPA comparisons.

> You're actually trying to disprove that "CC - expensive_tuition > Harvard - small_tuition in some cases"

No.

I'll admit that I made a slightly hyperbolic statement when I made a claim about kids in a class I never attended, but you belabor this point to such excess that I have no trouble calling it "nitpicking."

> Are you a betting man? What if one student had a bad day that day and got an 89?

Then my conclusion would not change in the slightest.

> Be careful making generalizations, man.

Right back at you. Slight hyperbole is one thing, straw men are another.

There are no comments on this comment yet.