Re:Testing the Resolution of the Human Eye
by jhonovich on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @06:42PM
(#6851428)
We are using IP cameras, that's our area of research / focus. As such, those types of cameras so not have a raw option.
We used H.264 with default quantization. We could have certainly used MJPEG, as these types of cameras support that but in our preliminary testing, it made no difference.
That said, I do agree that a completely uncompressed, raw, image could make a modest difference. For our domain, IP cameras, we just don't deal with raw images.
2. I'm going to disagree with the naysayers who say this is useless. You can partially defang them by pointing out that while this doesn't fully test a camera against a human eye, it is a reasonable test on its own merits and generally answers the question that people are actually asking when they ask "what's the resolution of the human eye?" (After all, the difference in capabilities goes both ways; sure, human eyes are a great deal more sensitive on many measures, but would someone please show me their eye's 10x optical zoom? (Hello to the 2040s!))
A further observation that "megapixels" is not useful would be called for, though. We're really comparing angular resolution for a certain set of settings. But we can accept "megapixels" as a slang term if we also fix certain other camera parameters to ones common to consumer cameras in the market.
3. Using eye charts is a good idea, I think. I've seen comparisons that try to compare rod density on the human eye, but that's really hard. I'd consider adding a note that standardized eye charts measure what humans can really see rather than try to compare two extremely different hardware platforms directly.