Re:Testing the Resolution of the Human Eye
by Sharlin on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @05:11PM
(#6850710)
People don't often realize how poor our visual acuity is everywhere outside the fovea, the area of sharp central vision a few degrees wide (that's a few fingers held together at an arm's length). We need saccades and microsaccades and lots of processing power and plain guesswork on part of the brain to patch together the image we "see". The resolution of a camera sensor, on the other hand, is not a function of the angular distance from the center of the image.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fovea_centralis
Re:Testing the Resolution of the Human Eye
by elwell on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @06:05PM
(#6851150)
This is an awesome comment!
Re:Testing the Resolution of the Human Eye
by trisweb on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @03:54PM
(#6850095)
Agreed, a eye to a camera is not a comparison, I've worked for a bit in computational vision after my PhD.
Our foveal vision makes the connection to digital camera sensors very unsteady. What we have is a spatial filter with diminished acuity as we move away from the focus of our vision.
We're actually processing what we believe to be a small amount of information in visual cortex. By the time objects make their way up the ventral visual system, they are encoded by very specific neurons firing for just that object. The brain is also thought to fill in a huge amount of information of our visual field.
You can't really leave the brain out of the equation when you estimate the sensitivity of our retina.
Re:Testing the Resolution of the Human Eye
by sp332 on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @03:44PM
(#6850028)
They mention that the camera has about 60-degree horizontal FOV. A 5MP 16:9 camera is about 2980x1680 pixels, so about 50 pixels per degree.
Re:Testing the Resolution of the Human Eye
by robertnealan on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @04:48PM
(#6850518)
Also seems to completely neglect that digital camera sensors perform wildly differently in low light situations independent of the actual image resolution.
The article didn't mention that every camera tested likely has a slightly different focal length / field of view. Two cameras with the same resolution but different focal lengths will score very differently in these tests. For example, a 32mm lens will see much more detail on the chart than a 14mm lens, even with the same resolution sensor.
Additionally, none of these cameras have the peripheral vision capabilities of the human eye. Our brains pick up quite a lot of information outside the tiny rectangle that these cameras are able to capture. The resolving power of the eye also changes from the center of our vision to the periphery - just because we can read the E on the chart in the middle of our eye doesn't mean we can read it from the edge of our vision.
Comparing eyes to cameras at this level of simplicity is mostly meaningless.