Re:How Old Is The Shepherd?
by yongjik on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @02:34PM
(#6849489)
> I fear you're making the calculation the end in itself (we have computers for that!)
Well, I have to disagree. Of course it's rather silly to make the calculation the goal in itself, but one needs to have a decent "feeling" of what would happen in a given domain. In math (up to college freshmen) or physics, that involves a lot of number-crunching. Until you get familiar with it.
It's same as CS students implementing quicksort, merge sort, heapsort, etc., even though when they graduate they will all use libraries. You can't really grok quicksort by reading the textbook and say "Hmm, I see."
Re:How Old Is The Shepherd?
by pflats on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @03:18PM
(#6849837)
You can grok most sorting methods remarkably well, though, by lining up a bunch of office junk on a big table and working through the sorting algorithm physically.
Well, I have to disagree. Of course it's rather silly to make the calculation the goal in itself, but one needs to have a decent "feeling" of what would happen in a given domain. In math (up to college freshmen) or physics, that involves a lot of number-crunching. Until you get familiar with it.
It's same as CS students implementing quicksort, merge sort, heapsort, etc., even though when they graduate they will all use libraries. You can't really grok quicksort by reading the textbook and say "Hmm, I see."