I guess I would want my kids too look at any math problem with the following things in mind: * identify units of measurement * identify useful data * identify non-useful data * identify assumptions needed to complete answer
There are more or different assumptions I could make, such as cooperative breeding amoungst other breeders or a larger flock to start with, or a completely different model of breeding sheep. I could have described a scenario where he started with 2 sheep and went through several trading and auction rounds until he had 125 with some bonus dogs like the guy that got a house from a paper clip.
We don't have a time measurement in years, so we need some type of sheep per time or time per sheep unit. I choose an assumption of breeding and came up with about 1 sheep per year per sheep.
The original question is very close to a nonsense question, which requires so many assumptions that probably most answers can be well defended with the right set of assumptions. But at the very least you would hope a student could identify an answer in years could not be obtained with the given data of # of sheep and # of dogs.
(And, no, I don't think the units method is beyond an eight grader, even if the educational system thinks it is. The fermi problem may be.)