Clearly the problems she gets in school are extremely rote and don't really require reading the problem much. Just look for a keyword or two and you can 'solve' it.
Teachers are being forced, now more than ever, to optimize for test scores, at the expense of real learning.
This isn't a video about stupid kids, it's a video about a stupid education system.
[1] http://reason.com/archives/2013/11/22/no-arne-duncan-white-s...
Not necessarily. It could just be that she is just learning how to answer tricky questions by using logic to determine what's not exactly spelled out.
That's about the same age that I started getting word problems that don't tell you specifically what you need to do so you have to 'find the problem'.
The problem I see right now doesn't have an immediate connection between the statement and the question parts. I have the numbers 125 and 5 and the question "how old is the shepherd?". I can see that the answer must be a person's age. The numbers refer to how many sheep and how many dogs are in the flock, which isn't really related to the shepherd's age. Still, there's probably some lateral thinking involved, or there's an omission, because I must obviously answer with a number.
If I add, subtract or multiply the two numbers in any order, I do not get a number that is plausible as a person's age. However, if I divide them, I get 25, which is totally a possible answer.
25 is also the number of sheep per dog. Assuming that that's a normal ratio for a flock, we can say that the shepherd's flock contains 5 flock-units. So if the shepherd started at 17 years old (very plausible in a rural setting) and was given a new flock-unit every two years (obviously as you get older you get to take on more responsibility), at age 25 the amount of responsibility would have grown to 5 flock-units.
This answer has a nice symmetry to it. Math answers have some sort of nice symmetry in them, so this sounds plausible. With the information given I can do no better.
Answer: 25 years old.
I do not think a reasonable justification is "Well all the other problems I had that looked like this had an easy answer so this one should too". And the fact, that several students were unable to kludge an answer together supports that.
>With the information given I can do no better. You can do a lot better! You can say that the question is unanswerable.
I don't see any evidence of that in the comments on the original article or here. All of it seems to be focussed on the process of education and the habits it forms and the psychology of teacher/student (or more general authority figure) relations.
But the point that I still think is an issue is that we don't know how much of the effect is about what the students _understand_ as much as it's about how they see the situation they are in. What incentives are there, and what is the student actually thinking?
While it may be the case that the education system fails to do enough at both of these, I suspect it does better at getting students to identify extraneous information and use only what is necessary than it does to get them to identify and confidently report when a question posed has inadequate information to support an answer.
I think this is a huge part of "mathematical thinking skills" that we claim we want to instill in students. It's a sad thing that most people don't really have a good definition of what a "mathematical thinking skill" is in the first place. Figuring out how to adequately and precisely pose questions is one of the MOST mathematical skills, but it rarely shows up in discussions of standards and curricula.
If students are going along solving word problems that always make sense, they have zero practice in identifying which questions are well posed and which aren't. It may not be that they're bad at reasoning through word problems, so much as they aren't used to word problems that make zero sense.
Given that context, it makes partial sense for a child to think "I must be making a mistake--I can't see how this problem works, but it must work somehow, because these problems always do make sense, even if sometimes I get them wrong, because I am not smart enough to understand them."
Is that a good attitude? Heck no. If nothing else, this experiment shows that we need to teach students that math problems aren't always going to be nicely set up so that they make sense. But that's different from thinking kids are dumb for not adapting to an unexpected wrinkle on a test.
An interesting companion experiment would be to prompt the students to explain the problem first, or see whether they could accurately determine which problems made sense and which didn't, when they knew that was what they were doing. My prediction is that the results would not be great, but that they'd be better.