News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: No More Passwords, Just Email by mschuster91 on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @11:05AM (#6847763)
Interesting concept - but what happens if you lose control of your email account (as a user)?

Imagine e.g. problems with your DNS (self-hosted and you forgot to renew the domain), outages of your mail provider, or the worst case (for the service provider): your outbound mail server is placed on a blacklist.

This way your entire user management system goes up in smoke without ANY way for you to fix it!

Re:Show HN: No More Passwords, Just Email by cbhl on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @11:15AM (#6847839)
"Send forgot password link to email account on file" is fairly common; if the user loses control of their email (e.g. to an attacker that got access to their password and then immediately changed it) then the user is already screwed in many ways. (I don't think this is ideal, but it seems to be the norm.)

Using email login links instead of passwords doesn't seem especially worse wrt. security than "industry standards".

Re:Show HN: No More Passwords, Just Email by deong on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @11:33AM (#6847986)
Except currently, I know most of my passwords. Losing my email access would suck on so many levels I don't know where to start, but at least I can still log into my bank/credit card sites/etc. to start mitigating the potential damage. If everyone went to a system like this, losing your email means losing access to everything you don't have an active cookie for, instantly and with no ability to recover.
Re:Show HN: No More Passwords, Just Email by nherment on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @11:08AM (#6847795)
It's an interesting concept and agree with the lost email access issue.

As for the other stuff (DNS, outage), it is a much bigger deal to loose these than an account at a 'nice to have' social website.

But this coupled with two factor authentication to recognise new computers is a nice idea.

Re:Show HN: No More Passwords, Just Email by StavrosK on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @11:13AM (#6847820)
If you lose your email as a user, you may be compromised (same thing that happens now). The provider's user management system stays as it was.
Re:Show HN: No More Passwords, Just Email by sbayona on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @11:09AM (#6847801)
A web server is subject to the same issues.
Re:Show HN: No More Passwords, Just Email by mschuster91 on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @11:14AM (#6847832)
Why? If my webserver goes down, I can move the hoster, reboot the server or otherwise fix the problem.

If my webserver or worse, my domain, ends up on a spam blacklist, either due to moronic/malicious users flagging my mails as spam or due to automatic triggering running amok, then I have no way of ever getting my sign-in working again except of praying that the blacklist manager(s) will unblock me. Which rarely happens.

Re:Show HN: No More Passwords, Just Email by icebraining on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @12:15PM (#6848352)
The webserver being in a blacklist can be solved by signing up to some SMTP relay. The domain blacklist can be solved by just buying another.

This is the perspective of the service provider. From the user POV, if their domain gets blacklisted, they can still receive emails, and therefore can still login as usual.