"We should make an app because if we don't Apple might reject the app we didn't make"?
The lead developer is probably more comfortable using Obj-C than web technologies
That is a terrible, awful, no good reason to restrict your target market. If a web site is worth making then it's worth making. Any lead developer worth giving even 1% of equity should be able to adapt to that. If you can do Objective C you can do the web.
The business is designed specifically for mobile users
If it's iOS only then the business is designed for a specific subset of mobile users. That's fine, but let's be clear. A responsive web site is also 'designed for mobile users'.
Don't complain now that you don't like them.
(and I didn't ask for reasons at any point but hey whatever)
Also, as you said, this is not either/or. If the lead was most comfortable with iOS but could also make a web app with a little more doing, then why not launch on iOS and then make a web app once the extra doing is taken care of?
-Apple is known for rejecting apps that mimic the functionality of the website (even the mobile version)
-The lead developer is probably more comfortable using Obj-C than web technologies
-The business is designed specifically for mobile users. Services like Luna already exist; they're trying to tap into a different demographic
-As such, iOS development is cheaper than both iOS and Android