Re:Two Centuries On, a Cryptologist Cracks a Presidential Code
by michael_dorfman on Thursday July 02, 2009 @05:45AM
(#684093)
True, but 200 years ago random numbers were harder to come by.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Two Centuries On, a Cryptologist Cracks a Presidential Code
by tetha on Thursday July 02, 2009 @07:15AM
(#684171)
You think they did not have some D10 and some D20? :)
Re:Two Centuries On, a Cryptologist Cracks a Presidential Code
by pmjordan on Thursday July 02, 2009 @07:41AM
(#684196)
As indicated by tetha's comment, that's not really true. Nature is a pretty good RNG. I was more amazed that someone who seems to have taken a keen interest in cryptography would not be concerned with generating good keys. Maybe I should expect that of someone who lived 200 years ago. I don't know.
(yes, the numbers could of course be truly random, but they don't seem it to me)
Re:Two Centuries On, a Cryptologist Cracks a Presidential Code
by michael_dorfman on Thursday July 02, 2009 @09:20AM
(#684315)
Just out of curiosity, what's your favorite technique for generating random numbers from nature? Let's say 7 numbers between 0 and 99.
Re:Two Centuries On, a Cryptologist Cracks a Presidential Code
by sgk284 on Thursday July 02, 2009 @02:24PM
(#684871)
They did have gambling back then. The roulette wheel came about in the 1800's, or they could have shuffled playing cards and drew some out of the deck, or thrown dice.
These aren't "natural" as in "from the earth", but they are trivial ways to calculate random numbers without assistance from a powered machine.
To answer your question though, I'd just flip a coin and calculate a random number in whatever range you want using binary.
Re:Two Centuries On, a Cryptologist Cracks a Presidential Code
by jimfl on Thursday July 02, 2009 @09:52AM
(#684378)
With a Lava Lamp:
Or with alpha-decay:
Re:Two Centuries On, a Cryptologist Cracks a Presidential Code
by michael_dorfman on Thursday July 02, 2009 @09:55AM
(#684383)
Either of those work well 200 years ago? I didn't think so.
Re:Two Centuries On, a Cryptologist Cracks a Presidential Code
by yan on Thursday July 02, 2009 @11:04AM
(#684494)
The thing with feeding truly random numbers to a person is that they never seem "random enough," so you'll have people rejecting a stochastic process because they see patterns, so they'll go out of their way to make it look more like noise, and decreasing the entropy.
Re:Two Centuries On, a Cryptologist Cracks a Presidential Code
by dan_the_welder on Thursday July 02, 2009 @02:30PM
(#684881)
"Here be chaotic bits"
I love the idea of this. Commodity hardware + smarts = awesome