News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why You Can't Build a Smartphone by TheLegace on Monday December 02, 2013 @05:24PM (#6837008)
Exactly rather than focusing why a smartphone can't succeed, I'd like to see how and why a phone can succeed.

If anyone thinks that the mess in the Play Store and the development environment of Android doesn't leave a bad taste in your mouth they should really re-consider thinking that Android is going to be around forever. I would like to ditch this platform the first moment I get. There are a lot niches that are not addressed by market players today, and the overlap between them can wedge a dent in the market. Google has serious weakness in hardware, and it looks like they will never get over that hump. Can you honestly expect them to optimize performance and battery life, if they can't even make their own devices.

Niches like:

Open-Source/Flexible development environment

Sustainability

Emerging Markets

Actual Innovation

Disruptive technologies and emerging markets shouldn't be counted out either. Nor should finding ways to monetize open-source. People, developers especially are increasingly looking for open platforms/devices, that market is NEVER going to get smaller only bigger.

Imagine actually being able to use Javascript or Python or Clojure for your apps, or scripts. Will you actually discount a platform where you can program without managing a thousand configuration files or worry about the gatekeepers(Google/Apple). See these problems aren't necessarily problems in Linux(not to say there aren't other drawbacks).

The great(maybe not?) thing about innovation is that if your to busy looking at the technology today your going to completely miss out what is coming next. - At least it's great if your competing.

I can't help thinking about what Jobs says, "Experts" are clueless.

>Experts—journalists, analysts, consultants, bankers, and gurus can’t “do” so they “advise.” They can tell you what is wrong with your product, but they cannot make a great one. [1]

[1]http://news.cnet.com/8301-13579_3-20117575-37/what-i-learned...

People seriously underestimate the power of a great product. Products that don't rely on massive feature lists that mean nothing a day after buying your device. I regret falling into this trap and wasting precious time instead of thinking about creating a better product experience. But again this is easier said than done.

Re:Why You Can't Build a Smartphone by ctdonath on Monday December 02, 2013 @07:10PM (#6837586)
I'd like to see how and why a phone can succeed.

There is an enormous market for a good dumb phone. Or, well, idiot savant phone: makes calls, makes calls well, and does nothing but makes calls. Between those who just don't want a smartphone, and those who carry enough computing power to not want yet another Cray 2 in a pocket, there's a large niche for a phone that is just a phone, syncs contacts effortlessly, eliminates every unnecessary/redundant call step, is just the right size & shape, uses every available network aggressively & seamlessly, leverages every service to save money, and has as clear & pristine a sound as makes audiophiles drool. Instead, we have fat folders with idiotic interfaces designed to make you spring for a smartphone just to get something thinner & easier.

I saw Smith Corona collapse. A market for typewriters remains to this day, decades later, untapped. Dumbphones are following the same path: a viable market wrecked by an industry dazzled by the sometimes undesirable glitz of a competitor.

Whither the iPhone nano? Many want it.

Re:Why You Can't Build a Smartphone by matthewmacleod on Monday December 02, 2013 @07:30PM (#6837671)
I don't really believe this market exists. And even if it does, I expect it's tiny - otherwise, manufacturers would be targeting it.
Re:Why You Can't Build a Smartphone by pgreenwood on Monday December 02, 2013 @08:41PM (#6837964)
Last night I had dinner with my parents. They lamented that they could not find a phone for my elderly grandmother. They just need something that just makes and receives calls, is dead simple, has (very) large buttons, and is loud. Where is this phone?

We have an ageing population.

Re:Why You Can't Build a Smartphone by some_guy_there on Monday December 02, 2013 @10:38PM (#6838322)
While this might not be the exact answer you were looking for, but people can buy a cheap android phone and put this launcher.

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=name.kunes.and...

Re:Why You Can't Build a Smartphone by dagw on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:37AM (#6839273)
They lamented that they could not find a phone for my elderly grandmother

Check out Doro (www.doro.com/). Quoting from the top of their website:

"Doro is a Swedish company developing telecom products specially adapted to the growing worldwide population of seniors."

Re:Why You Can't Build a Smartphone by voltagex_ on Monday December 02, 2013 @10:33PM (#6838301)
Something like http://www.telstra.com.au/mobile-phones/mobile-phones/telstr...?

(There was one with larger buttons, but I can't find it)

Re:Why You Can't Build a Smartphone by cflee on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @12:56AM (#6838854)
iNO Mobile here in Singapore has a whole series of elderly-targeted phones, here's one:

http://www.inomobile.com.sg/2012/07/ino-cp10/

actual retail price now is SGD 79, which is about USD 65. I'm not sure if I can get these at our 7-Elevens, but I think they have something similar with large keys.

Re:Why You Can't Build a Smartphone by dagw on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:40AM (#6839285)
There is an enormous market for a good dumb phone

I just ordered an Nokia 515 off ebay. Hopefully it will be what I'm looking for.

Re:Why You Can't Build a Smartphone by Jack000 on Monday December 02, 2013 @07:55PM (#6837773)
another idea:

a credit card sized e-paper device that can only do sms. It could be efficient enough to be powered by a peltier chip, so no need to charge it ever. Seems perfect for the text generation

Re:Why You Can't Build a Smartphone by pjc50 on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @08:41AM (#6840133)
Not enough power for the RF transmission; even if you go off-network while not in use (so you can't recieve SMS), then you still end up needing to do quite a few 2W burst transmissions to get back on and send the SMS.

Also, peltier requires a temperature difference; keeping it warm in your pocket is not enough.

Re:Why You Can't Build a Smartphone by S4M on Monday December 02, 2013 @06:09PM (#6837279)
What you describe seems exactly like the target of Firefox OS.
Re:Why You Can't Build a Smartphone by TheLegace on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @10:21AM (#6840738)
I actually hate the developing for the web, so FirefoxOS has no real interest for me. I'm grateful for the work those guys are doing, but I will never create HTML5 apps. I'm more of a systems, and robotics programmer and I love it but somehow these interests can never overlap with the way FirefoxOS functions.

So there isn't much of a value proposition for me.