Re:Why are Internet standards called “Request for Comments”?
by wpietri on Monday December 02, 2013 @12:13AM
(#6831795)
One of the things that I love about RFCs is that they're an existence proof.
Sometimes I'll get asked, "How can we have a successful organization without a lot of top-down control of X?" where X is something like architecture or process or coding standards or furniture choice. When people see problems, they imagine solutions pushed through a power structure. And of course, they imagine themselves as the ones in power, forgetting how many bullshit edicts they've had to deal with over the years.
The Internet and its RFCs are my favorite existence proof that you don't need centralized control to get good design and reliable systems. Indeed, you could argue that the Internet, beat out the other early networks because it wasn't centrally controlled.
Sometimes I'll get asked, "How can we have a successful organization without a lot of top-down control of X?" where X is something like architecture or process or coding standards or furniture choice. When people see problems, they imagine solutions pushed through a power structure. And of course, they imagine themselves as the ones in power, forgetting how many bullshit edicts they've had to deal with over the years.
The Internet and its RFCs are my favorite existence proof that you don't need centralized control to get good design and reliable systems. Indeed, you could argue that the Internet, beat out the other early networks because it wasn't centrally controlled.