News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why are Internet standards called “Request for Comments”? by gphilip on Sunday December 01, 2013 @08:59PM (#6830843)
Dustin Curtis' "response to the critcism" in that second link consists of:

1. Quoting a well-articulated email from yet another reader who felt deceived by the trickery; and,

2. (After a preface stating how he finds it amusing that so many people are bothered about this button) The following high-level technical overview of what happens behind the scenes when someone's kudos are volunteered willy-nilly:

  Here’s what it actually does: when you hover over the button, a CSS transform animation is activated which fills 
  the circle. After 1 second (the length of the animation), it fires a request to the server which increments an 
  otherwise meaningless number by exactly one.
This is the full extent of his response. As far as I could figure out, this "response to criticism" addresses the following introductory paragraph of his interlocutor's email:

  I was curious about the Kudos button you mention in your http://dcurt.is/web-standards article. I hovered over it 
  with my mouse pointer, and then it said “don’t move”. I didn’t move. Then it said “sent”. Apparently someone 
  invented a button that does not need to be pressed in order to be triggered.
And totally ignores the sentiment communicated by the more weighty second paragraph which concludes with:

  I very humbly request that you kindly decrement the Kudos statistic by one unit in order to compensate for the 
  one that I definitely did not intend to send until it was forcefully withdrawn from me by a deceitful human 
  interface.
Did Dustin Curtis really miss the subtle (svbtle?) sarcasm of that first paragraph, or am I just imagining things?
Re:Why are Internet standards called “Request for Comments”? by xerophtye on Monday December 02, 2013 @01:05AM (#6832019)
Wait a minute, so he didn't realize that the criticism is that it performs a function without me wanting to perform it, and thinks the criticism is that "i feel it sucks out my soul" -_- Seriously, why DID the GP link to this?