News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Critique this idea by pmichaud on Wednesday July 01, 2009 @11:03AM (#682739)
What you were thinking and what the system would eventually become are two different things. I'm saying the inevitable consequence of a system like that would be the scenario I described.

Do you think company stocks started out that complex? No, they started out as an intuitive way to divide the profits of a business operated by multiple people, just like your intuitive way of dividing profits from a project built by multiple people.

Edge cases presented themselves, conflicts arose, opportunities for individuals to maximize profit came to light, and thus was our current system grown.

Re:Ask HN: Critique this idea by ErrantX on Wednesday July 01, 2009 @11:27AM (#682785)
ok fair points; I assumed you were pointing out flawqs based on the model I mis-represented.

Im not 100% sure I agree the problem would be as dramatic/bad as your presenting though.