Re:I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made
by dragonwriter on Saturday November 30, 2013 @08:20PM
(#6825581)
If you use as weak and binary a definition of "capitalism" as you expressly state that you are, then the idea of nations inevitably trending toward capitalism is even more ludicrous than it is if you use it in a meaningful way -- as it is, even currently socialist nations are "capitalist" (not trending toward it -- which is impossible, there is no way to have a variable distance from it -- but actually capitalist.)
Re:I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made
by notdrunkatall on Saturday November 30, 2013 @09:26PM
(#6825774)
Yes, I've noticed that debates with those who advocate socialism over capitalism tend to devolve into arguments over semantics.
It seems that so very few of you can argue in favor of your favorite alternative to capitalism well enough to refrain from nitpicking. It becomes tiresome after a while.
Re:I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made
by dragonwriter on Sunday December 01, 2013 @02:19AM
(#6826480)
Using your weak definition of capitalism, I've rarely seen anyone advocate socialism over capitalism, since all socialism that I've seen advocated is compatible with (and even require) your weak definition of capitalism, they aren't alternatives to it.
And, while there's probably some definitions of "socialism" and "capitalism" for which my preferred tuning of a modern mixed economy is more "socialism" than "capitalism", all I've been arguing in this thread is that your Marx-in-reverse arguments about the inevitability of capitalism are as ludicrous as Marxist fanatics arguments about the inevitability of Communism -- and that's not even related to advocacy about the desirability of any system.
Re:I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made
by notdrunkatall on Sunday December 01, 2013 @07:54AM
(#6827085)
Semantics.
By the actual definition of "communism" there are no communist nations today, nor were there ever any for the reasons I gave in my initial argument. The definition of communism I've used for this discussion was actually more lenient than how it is defined.
>The Communist Party of Cuba would be as surprised to learn that they aren't Communist
The Communist Party of Cuba would not be surprised at all. They're just playing the game they've been given, and to think that they don't know the score is to assume they are all idiots right off the bat.
>At any rate, the idea that all nations eventually trend towards capitalism is ludicrous
Every formerly communist/socialist nation on the planet save one has moved to liberalize their economy in the last few decades, because communism/socialism is inherently flawed. All nations do, indeed, inevitably trend towards capitalism. If they choose not to, they inevitably fail, and once they pick up the pieces, they inevitably choose the alternative, which has been proven to succeed time and time again.