And, given the need for explicit referents preceding uses of pronouns (other than "one"/"many", which aren't the kind of pronouns at issue here), using them properly doesn't negatively impact searching.
You're telling me that "it" or "they" riddled more often than otherwise does not negatively affect search results? Pronouns increase the chance irrelevant results. This is implied by your use of "properly"; which only begs the question.
Basically. More specifically, I would say that using definite pronouns improves search results.
> Pronouns increase the chance irrelevant results.
No, because there is no reason to search for definite pronouns, you search for the nouns that are the antecedents of definite pronouns (since using a definite pronoun requires using a noun as an antecedent in writing -- this can be substituted by gesture or other non-verbal cues in oral communication.) And if you use pronouns, you get less result clutter for those searches for the same reasons that you get better readability, you have less close-proximity repetition of the key nouns.
Using "it/they/them" decreases findability and grep-ability of the Documentation.
Generally pronouns increase the signal-to-noise ratio. "The User" or less noise increases the visibility and viability of search hooks.
We should find a way to (a) drop pronouns all together, which ultimately involves (b) rewriting the sentence, or (c) writing with explicitness.