Re:To my friends in the Node community
by jiggy2011 on Saturday November 30, 2013 @02:12PM
(#6824158)
But that's also clumsy because you end up with sentences like:
"The user switches on the user's computer and types the user's name".
Rather than the shorter and better flowing: "The user switches on her computer and types her name"
We have the concept of "user stories" the idea of which is that they read like stories. Since stories tend to have gendered characters (even when not necessary) this is just the sort of writing that tends to work best in english.
Re:To my friends in the Node community
by tunesmith on Saturday November 30, 2013 @02:49PM
(#6824342)
"The user switches on their computer and types their name"?
More like "the user switches on the computer and types a username."
User stories a tiny portion of product development, not the sort of writing that works best for technical applications.
Re:To my friends in the Node community
by __pThrow on Saturday November 30, 2013 @02:18PM
(#6824184)
her is still better than them!
I don't understand how. Is the user female? Must she be? Why did the author choose a gendered pronoun when they had a gender-neutral one available to them? There must have been a reason; the author isn't assumed to be ignorant of basic English.
Also, "her" is "still" better? "Still"?
I can't think of many situations where user activity won't also be automated, what's the gender of a testing script again?
There's really no good reason for gendered pronouns.