News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An example of fast numerical computation using Haskell by killercup on Saturday November 30, 2013 @08:06AM (#6823040)
I was bored and curious to know how the Collatz conjecture works.

Then, I implemented it in Lua and JS and compared their performance to C and Haskell. It's not meant to be a (good) benchmark. Here you go: https://gist.github.com/killercup/7718804

tl;dr

    Implementation | Time 
    -------------- | -----
    clang 3.3      | 0.40s
    luajit 2.0.2   | 0.86s
    GHC 7.6.3      | 0.49s
    Node 0.10.22   | 2.43s
Re:An example of fast numerical computation using Haskell by xdenser on Saturday November 30, 2013 @10:54AM (#6823433)
my 2 cents to defend NodeJs

   329 837799
   naive 3.06 sec
   329 837799
   decompozed 3.03 sec
   329 837799
   memoized decompozed 0.52 sec
The program https://gist.github.com/xdenser/7722083
Re:An example of fast numerical computation using Haskell by dbaupp on Saturday November 30, 2013 @05:46PM (#6825023)
Presumably the Lua, c and Haskell programs would also be 6× faster if you use the memoised algorithm, so that's a pretty meaningless comparison.
Re:An example of fast numerical computation using Haskell by xdenser on Sunday December 01, 2013 @10:49AM (#6827700)
Ok this intArithm variant (w/o memoization) for NodeJS is 6 times faster (0.54 sec) comparing to naive

        function intArithm(){
        var
            max_a0 = +process.argv[2],
            longest = 0,
            max_len = 0, a0,len, a,z;

        for(a0=1;a0<=max_a0;++a0){
            a = a0;
            len = 0;
            while( a != 1){
                len++;
                z = a >>> 1;
                a = (!(a&1))?z:(a+z+1);
            }
            if(len>max_len){
                max_len = len;
                longest = a0;
            }
        }
        console.log(max_len,longest);
        }
the problem was with division by 2 operation which is not integer in js. So replacing it with shift >>> makes the trick. Formula optimization gives additional 200 ms.

And I doubt memoized c or lua variant will be 6 times faster than non-memoized. As it is not that linear.