News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made by markdown on Saturday November 30, 2013 @07:59AM (#6823023)
> I hope you won't bother pulling a No True Scotsman here, because the list goes on.

Then use another example from your list. North Korea is a totalitarian dictatorship. It's not exactly clear whether its woes are the result of its economic system or its form of governance.

Re:I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made by cynicalkane on Saturday November 30, 2013 @08:23AM (#6823074)
Communism in the formal sense, which is Marxist socialism or one of its offshoots, requires state control by definition. It can't be a "true scotsman" unless it's a dictatorship. Communist theory does not allow for democratic socialism, because it proposes real "democracy" is the "dictatorship of the proletariat", Marx's words.
Re:I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made by moocowduckquack on Saturday November 30, 2013 @08:41AM (#6823131)
Which communist theory? There are now as many communist theories as there are variations on the People's Front of Judea from Life of Brian and many of them explicitly reject state control and are closer to US libertarianism than either side would really care to admit.

edit - adding 'in the formal sense' to your post doesn't really change things. Formally, communism is supposed to be a developing theory, which is part of the reason for Marx famously saying that he wasn't a Marxist. Formally, communist theory, as envisioned by Marx, was never meant to be frozen as dogma, but rather relentlessly self-critical. Whether he was right or not is a seperate issue, but you are seriously misrepresenting his ideas.

Re:I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made by steveklabnik on Saturday November 30, 2013 @09:40AM (#6823251)
You misunderstand what 'dictatorship' means in that context. The word didn't have the same connotation it has today.

Specifically, capitalism is the 'dictatorship of the bourguise,' so it needs to be counteracted by a dictatorship of the proletariat. Within the governing body, democratic councils run things. To draw a parallel to today's concept of 'dictatorship,' think of it this way: one class has absolute, total rule of things. But a class is made up of many people...

Re:I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made by paradoja on Saturday November 30, 2013 @08:31AM (#6823094)
Nope.

The dictatorship of the proletariat is not communism. Not even for Marx. It is the state before communism, in which the proletariat makes changes in society so that communism may take place.

Re:I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made by cynicalkane on Saturday November 30, 2013 @09:25AM (#6823218)
Nice try, but I explicitly stated I was talking about Marxist-style socialism, which is what 'communism' has come to mean. I almost never see people talk about "real" Marxist communism anyway.
Re:I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made by paradoja on Saturday November 30, 2013 @10:31AM (#6823367)
You explicitly said "Communism in the formal sense". You were wrong with that.

Most ideologies and political or economic ideas have had their names subverted to mean something different by opponents (democracy, republicanism, communism, anarchism, capitalism...). That doesn't mean that if you speak in the "formal sense" you can decide to use whatever meaning you prefer.

Re:I Tried to See Where My T-Shirt Was Made by VMG on Saturday November 30, 2013 @08:09AM (#6823047)
USSR, GDR, Cuba? Of course they are all totalitarian dictatorships, but that's what you get with communism.