Re:How Software Companies Die by Orson Scott Card (1995)
by d4nt on Friday November 29, 2013 @06:08AM
(#6818912)
I get the feeling Colin may have already automated this and it's a bot posting these things.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:How Software Companies Die by Orson Scott Card (1995)
by ColinWright on Friday November 29, 2013 @06:18AM
(#6818939)
I did have, but it's been permanently disabled. I got too much grief over it. I have scripts to assist, but all these posts are "by hand". They don't take much time, and occasionally during the search and confirmation phase I stumble across other things that are interesting, so there is some reward.
Re:How Software Companies Die by Orson Scott Card (1995)
by keithpeter on Friday November 29, 2013 @10:12AM
(#6819636)
Script assisted manual commands are something I use a lot as well, I can hack up scripts and cope with minor changes in data format &c.
I'm interested in the reaction to automated posting but the comparative acceptance of 'by hand' posting. Is that simply frequency? Are you selecting which historic threads to run searches against?
Re:How Software Companies Die by Orson Scott Card (1995)
by ColinWright on Friday November 29, 2013 @10:59AM
(#6819849)
I think in part many people were just upset at having a 'bot posting. Thin end of the wedge, and all that. Others didn't like the tone of the message, seeing it as a rebuke.
This is why when I do it "by hand" I make sure I hunt out previous discussions, and if there are none, make a note of that. I can script it all, but with the general hostility I've decided that I'll run the searches for myself because there are often interesting things turn up. Then I post my results because, well, why not? If I found it interesting, others may as well.
More than once I've caught myself constructing replies on negative results and deleted them. I may yet just stop entirely.
Re:How Software Companies Die by Orson Scott Card (1995)
by chris_wot on Friday November 29, 2013 @08:22PM
(#6821839)
I, for one, would be very sad if you stopped posting to HN.
Re:How Software Companies Die by Orson Scott Card (1995)
by tokenadult on Friday November 29, 2013 @11:43AM
(#6820023)
I deeply appreciate Colin's posts about previous submissions and routinely upvote them. What I like about them, as someone who has been on Hacker News 1838 days now, is that they answer the "Haven't I seen this before?" question that often pops into my mind when I see a recurrently posted story. Because this site's name is Hacker News, after all, I expect to see new stories submitted here, so when an old story is submitted it's helpful to know where the previous discussion is.
Re:How Software Companies Die by Orson Scott Card (1995)
by Udo on Friday November 29, 2013 @06:19AM
(#6818944)
I think it makes sense to have that bot as an actual separate site feature. Personally, it's not something I'd want to be mixed in with normal comments.
Re:How Software Companies Die by Orson Scott Card (1995)
by narag on Friday November 29, 2013 @06:33AM
(#6818983)
What about offering it as a service to the submitter from the submission page?
Re:How Software Companies Die by Orson Scott Card (1995)
by keithpeter on Friday November 29, 2013 @10:14AM
(#6819646)
I have taken the precaution of searching for phrases in titles of older pages before submitting (I submit seldom) and have not submitted if previously discussed.
Such a feature would be good I think.