News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Problem with Higher Education - An Unfortunate Email by graycat on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @03:08AM (#6807059)
> At a point in history when self tutoring often provides more than the average Graduate course, it blows my mind how difficult it can be to get into a Masters program.

Things to consider:

(1) Take the GRE tests for both aptitude and your speciality. Really good scores will be tough to ignore. And if your speciality is in a STEM field, then you get to f'get about all the English literature, history, etc. and your grades in those nonsense subjects.

(2) Emphasize points of success in your career. Why? Because you will look like you are taking your career seriously and might later in your career be able to make significant financial contributions to the university. Yes, Virginia, universities like rich students!

(3) As in the quote, do some independent study. Then in your application, describe the significant books and journal papers you have studied. You may be doing enough independent study now just for your career.

(4) Get the description of the Ph.D. qualifying exams. Mostly the coursework for a Master's and for preparation for the exams are similar. So, just study the darned material on your own, apply to the Ph.D. program, and offer to sit for the qualifying exams before being admitted. Offer tough to turn down.

Note, at one time the Web site of the Princeton math department just flatly stated that the graduate courses were introductions to research by experts, no courses were given for preparation for the qualifying exams, and students were expected to prepare for these exams on their own. So, do it, on your own, without going to campus.

That you successfully prepared for the qualifying exams on your own is big time impressive and a big point for any graduate program because one of the basic necessary conditions for success in a Ph.D. program is good ability at independent study. So, showing such ability can make a graduate department really happy, i.e., no longer afraid they will have to write your dissertation for you.

(5) Find a problem, maybe at work, that needs solving and get a good solution, both in theory and in practice. Write a paper and submit it for publication in a peer-reviewed journal or a conference.

If are unsure on just how to do this, then find a friendly Ph.D., researcher, professor to give you the 101 Big Secrets They Never Taught You in College on How Get a Paper Published or some such.

Pretend to look for a recommendation of a suitable journal and write to a suitable professor in the program you want to enter and send a copy of your paper. So, prime the pump via a backdoor. If he likes your paper, then it can be that all the rest goes quickly. E.g., once I applied to a graduate program at Cornell and got turned down. It happened that there was a prof there I wanted to talk to about a problem I had at work and flew up. We took a campus tour, and back at his office I showed him my problem and my progress on it. Suddenly I got another letter from the department admissions saying I was in. I didn't go. Via such things I also got into Brown, Princeton, and Hopkins. I went to Hopkins.

(6) Typically a STEM department has a seminar series. These can be painful as a toothache because you may be listening to stuff you don't have the prerequisites to understand. But they can also be good because they can, on a good day, give you some great help in picking a research problem.

Well, typically such seminars are open to the public, and maybe also the department tea before the seminar. So, crash the party and meet some of the profs and/or graduate students. From the students, get some of the 'low down' -- they can be quite helpful to a fellow suffering human.

You need to know that graduate school, really, is not much about learning. Instead, the three most important aspects are research, research, and research, as in "new, correct, and significant" and/or "worthy of publication". For a prof, what's important is research good enough to get a good grant, e.g., from the NSF. E.g., that Princeton Web site didn't even want to teach basic material and only wanted students to get involved in research; the assumption is that hard part was doing the research, not finding, reading, and understanding it in the library.

As a graduate student, do some work that is nice and clearly publishable, especially if you publish it, and can suddenly find that life in the department gets much nicer.

Finally, my Secret Guide to Research Success in STEM Fields is, "be wise, mathematize". Basically get an ugrad math major with emphasis on topics that can be important in the other STEM fields and then make the research basically some new theorems and proofs. It's worked for me.

For the admissions office, try to f'get about them! They just can't be the brightest bulbs on the tree.

There are no comments on this comment yet.