Re:YouTube Addresses Massive Spam Problem Following Rollout ...
by vor_ on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @07:35PM
(#6805383)
This is a controversial change, and praising the new system while neglecting to mention that you work for Google risks coming off like astroturfing, regardless of your intentions. I think enough people can be reasonable and take your opinions into consideration even if your employer is the topic of conversation.
Re:YouTube Addresses Massive Spam Problem Following Rollout ...
by jrockway on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @11:06PM
(#6806288)
That's fine. It's good to consider the source of the argument in addition to its content. I take a neutral view because I don't really care one way or the other; if this was jrockway Inc., I might not have done the change in the same way. But perhaps that's why there is no such thing as jrockway Inc., and there is a such thing as G+ and YouTube. Who knows.
Re:YouTube Addresses Massive Spam Problem Following Rollout ...
by josephlord on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @06:36PM
(#6805089)
Nothing I see on the first couple of pages of Google. A link might be more helpful.
Re:YouTube Addresses Massive Spam Problem Following Rollout ...
by rallison on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @10:41PM
(#6806173)
I assume it is this that he is referencing: http://searchengineland.com/google-clarifies-no-ads-shouldnt...
Re:YouTube Addresses Massive Spam Problem Following Rollout ...
by jrockway on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @11:04PM
(#6806281)
Yup! Makes me look pretty dumb, doesn't it :)
(Also: never go up against the SEO blogs! They have good SEO! :)
Re:YouTube Addresses Massive Spam Problem Following Rollout ...
by josephlord on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @05:47AM
(#6807462)
I'm not sure avoiding putting a disclosure of interest will avoid that sort of thing. I think when discussing anything related to your employer you need to be really careful.
Opinion should always be disclosed as such with disclosure and probably normally a disclaimer that it your personal view and not that of your company although if it is a statement of pure fact I think it is OK to post anonymously and/or without disclaimer.
Your comment about G+ above is very much opinion.
A factual statement correcting another post "you can now do X by going to Y" in response to a complaint that you can't do X is for me fine even if related to your employer and you don't disclose anything.
Working for myself now means I don't have to worry about contradicting my employer or embarrassing them, it is a nice freedom to have.
Most long-time readers of HN know where I work, and I target my comments in that direction, rather than to anyone that happens to stumble upon this page. My apologies.