News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Andrea Rossi has started commercializing ECAT nuclear fus... by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @02:32PM (#6803574)
> Yes, but you see, that is a marketing claim, not a physical one. If it were true, Rossi would be sequestered with a team of crack lawyers attempting to secure patent protection for his breakthrough

As for patents on perpetual motion devices, the Patent Office is geared to reject claimed cold fusion patents that don't include a demonstration of a working device (of course, the reason for this is such claims have proven irreproducible, which impinges on the utility test for patentability.)

Re:Andrea Rossi has started commercializing ECAT nuclear fus... by BerislavLopac on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @12:46PM (#6809733)
Shouldn't this be a requirement for all patents?
Re:Andrea Rossi has started commercializing ECAT nuclear fus... by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @02:55PM (#6810649)
> Shouldn't this be a requirement for all patents?

It has to demonstrate utility for all patents; but utility doesn't generally require a working device (even for patents of a "device" type).

Whether it should is an interesting question, but if its clear from the information in the patent and the information generally available outside of it that a practitioner in the field could derive real utility from the described mechanism, I think there's at least a clear argument that actually having a demonstrated device is unnecessary, while with ones whose claims appear to violate physical laws or be of a class where claims have shown to be impossible to reproduce by other practitioners, the demonstration of a working device to demonstrate utility is important.