Re:Farming hard drives: 2 years and $1M later
by jotm on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @11:55AM
(#6802475)
High failure rates of external drives can also be attributed to the USB controllers - they're better than their IDE predecessors (which failed a lot, sometimes taking the drives with them - only low level utilities could revive them).
Otherwise, I don't see how or why the hard drive manufacturers would bother to send the worst batches (which aren't that much worse) to external hard drive assemblers.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Farming hard drives: 2 years and $1M later
by ZoFreX on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @01:28PM
(#6803130)
I repair computers for friends and families and the majority of the time I get a broken external to look at, it's the enclosure that's at fault and the drive is absolutely fine.
I encourage people to buy their enclosures and drives separately - it's a little more expensive, but this way you can RMA just the enclosure if it fails. With an all-in-one, you either void your warranty to get the data back, or ship the whole unit back for a replacement.
Re:Farming hard drives: 2 years and $1M later
by jotm on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @02:00PM
(#6810283)
That's an interesting point, since I have a Samsung hard drive I took OUT of an enclosure and out of curiosity I checked the warranty on it - it's a 3 year warranty that is still active and the web page said I could initiate a return.
So, technically, I could RMA the drive myself if it fails... or would they notice it and not process the return?
Re:Farming hard drives: 2 years and $1M later
by sp332 on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @12:10PM
(#6802591)
It could also be that they shut down more frequently. More stop-start cycles mean more wear on the moving parts of the disk.
Re:Farming hard drives: 2 years and $1M later
by bentcorner on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @12:28PM
(#6802719)
Isn't that a feature of the USB enclosure? (i.e., not an issue once a drive has been "shucked")