News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Andrea Rossi has started commercializing ECAT nuclear fus... by busterarm on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @10:36AM (#6801897)
I'm not swayed by the fact sheet. I understand physics. I also know enough to know that we don't really know shit. Things happen that prove earlier notions to be wrong. It used to be that we all KNEW that the Earth was flat, and that it was the center of the universe too. There could be something going on here that we don't understand. I'm not saying that's what's happening, but I want to attack his claims ONLY by measurables.

All I am saying is let's prove his claims to be bullshit _by measurement_. Otherwise we're doing nothing but putting out more hot air than this generator does.

Re:Andrea Rossi has started commercializing ECAT nuclear fus... by lutusp on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @10:45AM (#6801944)
> There could be something going on here that we don't understand.

In science, the null hypothesis rules. The null hypothesis -- the premise that something is false until evidence proves otherwise -- is why scientists have a reputation for skepticism. It also filters out claims like this one.

A scientist wouldn't give Rossi the benefit of the doubt. A scientist would demand scientific evidence, not a marketing sheet with some very obvious defects.

> I understand physics.

If you understand physics, why has it not occurred to you to ask why Rossi doesn't use 200 KW of the claimed 1 MW output power to remove the input power requirement? How hard is that?

> All I am saying is let's prove his claims to be bullshit _by measurement_.

No! The burden of evidence belongs to Rossi, not to his critics (see below). He cannot meet that burden.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell's_teapot

Re:Andrea Rossi has started commercializing ECAT nuclear fus... by busterarm on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @10:52AM (#6801993)
> If you understand physics, why has it not occurred to you to ask why Rossi doesn't use 200 KW of the claimed 1 MW output power to remove the input power requirement? How hard is that?

What makes you think that it hasn't occurred to me? Maybe I just don't think it's worth posting about until Rossi has a physical product we can test?

> No! The burden of evidence belongs to Rossi, not to his critics (see below). He cannot meet that burden. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell's_teapot

Again, no disagreement, but you're starting your attack before he has a finished product with which he can attempt to meet that burden.

Just because you know something, doesn't mean that you need to be aggressive about it. You're actually giving Rossi more attention than he deserves before these things are ready to be tested.

You talk about the null hypothesis and filtering out claims and not even giving him the benefit of the doubt. Absolutely. A scientist who has useful things to do with their time just ignores it until there is evidence otherwise.

Going on the attack is something completely different.

Edit: ^ The moment that I realize I'm arguing about this with a legit scientist who I have major respect for and whose site I've read on occasion. :(

Re:Andrea Rossi has started commercializing ECAT nuclear fus... by lutusp on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @05:54PM (#6804881)
> What makes you think that it hasn't occurred to me?

Because it's a fatal error and you didn't mention it.

> Maybe I just don't think it's worth posting about until Rossi has a physical product we can test?

What, so uneducated people can be scammed out of their life savings? Where's your sense of public duty?

His claims are bogus. If he had achieved what he claims, he would not be calling for 200 KW of input power. And even given that absurd premise, assuming this fantasy requirement as a thought experiment, he could use one of his small units to power five small units of the same kind, then five to power 25, etc., resulting in a very small initial power input for a vast output power.

The reason the "fact sheet" isn't written that way is because this guy doesn't even know how to lie convincingly.

> Edit: ^ The moment that I realize I'm arguing about this with a legit scientist who I have major respect for and whose site I've read on occasion. :(

That shouldn't matter as you evaluate my claims, any more than it should matter in evaluating Rossi's claims. Evidence should be the only issue.

A guy once said, "In science, evidence means everything, reputation means nothing. The greatest amount of scientific eminence is trumped by the smallest amount of scientific evidence."

Oh, wait, that guy was me. :)

Re:Andrea Rossi has started commercializing ECAT nuclear fus... by CWuestefeld on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @11:03AM (#6802083)
why Rossi doesn't use 200 KW of the claimed 1 MW output power to remove the input power requirement?

Because it's necessary to input the power to bootstrap the reaction. Of course, that just begs the question: why not say it's only needed for start-up? I suppose that there could be engineering concerns...

Don't get me wrong, I believe this is baloney. But I don't think the argument about requiring input power is what proves that.

Re:Andrea Rossi has started commercializing ECAT nuclear fus... by lutusp on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @06:00PM (#6804913)
>> why Rossi doesn't use 200 KW of the claimed 1 MW output power to remove the input power requirement?

> Because it's necessary to input the power to bootstrap the reaction.

Yes, but his megawatt unit consists of dozens of smaller units, each of which (if we accept the premise for the moment) requires a much smaller amount of bootstrap power. Therefore, logically, he would power one unit with a tiny bootstrap kick, that unit would use its generated power to sustain itself and bootstrap four additional units, four would bootstrap 16, all with surplus power. Logical, yes?

Anyone with the slightest familiarity with science and technology would see this is the logical arrangement, but it appears Rossi doesn't have the slightest familiarity with science and technology.

Re:Andrea Rossi has started commercializing ECAT nuclear fus... by carbocation on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @10:42AM (#6801930)
> All I am saying is let's prove his claims to be bullshit _by measurement_.

If we did that for everyone trying to sell a highly flawed device with engineering requirements that are not yet mastered by even world experts, we could measure such claims all day and achieve no real benefit. It is his job to demonstrate this to us.

It is possible that this device is actually performing better-than-breakeven fusion. But I would happily bet money against it.