Re:Farming hard drives: 2 years and $1M later
by ewams on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @10:51AM
(#6801986)
In the parent article they said they switched because of cost: "When Hitachi drives got too expensive we switched to Seagate and Western Digital. When internal drives got too expensive we turned to external drives. When hard drive availability became an issue we turned to Drive Farming."
From their article on v2 they said: "The Western Digital and Seagate equivalents we tested saw much higher rates of popping out of RAID arrays and drive failure. Even the Western Digital Enterprise Hard Drives had the same high failure rates. The Hitachi drives, on the other hand, perform wonderfully." http://blog.backblaze.com/2011/07/20/petabytes-on-a-budget-v...
There are other articles where they mention that they do testing and some brands perform better than others.
Re:Farming hard drives: 2 years and $1M later
by sard420 on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @11:22AM
(#6802233)
We used to make PODs like this at work for netbackup storage.. started with WD drives ~128 WD drives, at about two years we were at ~8 WD drives still working. At least once a week we had people in there swapping drives. I have yet to see a WD not fail.
Re:Farming hard drives: 2 years and $1M later
by dublinben on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @12:18PM
(#6802647)
On the other hand, I've got a WD Caviar Black that's been running strong for more than five years. None of my WD drives have ever failed (knock on wood!). I don't run 100+ drives though, so I'm probably just hiding in the statistical margin.
Re:Farming hard drives: 2 years and $1M later
by miahi on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @01:34PM
(#6803175)
Your Caviar Black is trumped by my two Scorpio Blacks I had to RMA in one year because of strange read/write delays and clicking noise. No actual failure, but it started from one problem/day when I bought them to 3-4/hour when I sent them back.
Re:Farming hard drives: 2 years and $1M later
by dspillett on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @03:23PM
(#6803934)
Also your thermal environment is going to be quite different, which could be a significant factor. How often do you power-cycle that drive BTW? I've had more drives go bad on power-up (just failing to spin up and move the heads correctly) than through surface errors and such.
Re:Farming hard drives: 2 years and $1M later
by dublinben on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @06:39PM
(#6805109)
I try not to restart that machine more than once a month.
Re:Farming hard drives: 2 years and $1M later
by dspillett on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @11:35AM
(#6809086)
That si better than running the drives 24/7 - if one is going to go then that way it is more likely to go alone. If every in an array (anything I even half way care about get s the RAID1 or RAID5 treatment) has been spinning for years then a power cycle can be quite scary. Restarting once month or so increases the chance that if they fail they'll not all fail at the same time.
Having said that, my main little server at home hasn't had a power cycle for somewhat longer than a month as there have been no kernel updates or that like that have required it...
Re:Farming hard drives: 2 years and $1M later
by tachion on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @10:33AM
(#6801870)
It doesnt implicate that Hitachi were not the same quality as others. I undestand that the main reason to switch was the availability to price ratio, nothing else. What I think they meant when talking about drives to be different is the variety of sizes you get when purchasing 'a 3TB' drive.
"Switching hard drive manufacturers from Hitachi to Seagate and Western Digital. The assumption here is that all drives are the same and as we’ve learned that’s not really the case."
Where is the footnote. Why aren't they the same?