http://gizmodo.com/5824912/who-is-really-snuffing-out-americ...
http://www.wired.com/gadgetlab/2011/05/app-store-patent-trol...
Damned near all patent troll are based in hickville towns. It is not coincidence and it is not because the judges are "experienced" with patent cases. It is because those judges side with the plaintiffs.
"No Texas district is even in the top 5 for win rates for patent plaintiffs. You'd think if they were "in the pockets" of patent trolls, the trolls would achieve better outcomes there."
Because they shouldn't win any of these software patent cases. We're talking about trolls...businesses whose only purpose is to shake down people who build real products for real people. Every damned one of these cases should be laughed out of court. They go to Marshall because they won't get laughed out of court.
Not necessarily. If all the plaintiffs with poor-quality patents sue in that district (and they mostly do), those losing cases will pull down the patent plaintiff win rate for the district.
So it could still be the most patent-plaintiff-friendly district, even if the win rate is lower there.
The actual reasons filing patent cases in EDTX is popular are:
• EDTX does not have a busy Federal criminal case load. Criminal cases have higher priority than civil cases. If you try to litigate a complex civil case in a district that has a heavy criminal load (e.g., anywhere that has a lot of drug trafficking), it can be nearly impossible to get any court time.
• Patent cases are complex. If you have a judge with little experience with patent cases, things will go slow. So, people like to file in districts that have a few judges with patent case experience.