News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FDA Warning Letter to 23andMe by dragonwriter on Monday November 25, 2013 @02:22PM (#6796262)
> The 23andme product explains explicitly how it should be used by a physician

Generally, for diagnostic tools, drugs, etc., it is not enough that the product labelling explains how it should be used, but it is required to demonstrate to the FDA that there is evidence that it works as marketed when used according to those directions. The FDA Warning Letter specifically calls out 23andMe's failure to either identify existing approved products on the market to which the product is equivalent (which wouldn't reduce the requirements for proving this) or to meet the requirements for demonstrating the effectiveness of their offering as a new product without existing, approved equivalents.

Re:FDA Warning Letter to 23andMe by grandalf on Monday November 25, 2013 @02:31PM (#6796311)
How do you think 23andme should answer that question?

There are at least three different products in the space and to claim similarity would be to likely invite over-regulation:

- "full scan" companies, that do a full genetic scan and do not limit the scan to SNPs

- personal genomics companies that focus on SNPs

- medial diagnostics like the MSAFP test

Re:FDA Warning Letter to 23andMe by dragonwriter on Monday November 25, 2013 @02:45PM (#6796418)
> How do you think 23andme should answer that question?

I don't know enough about 23andMe's operations and those of what appear from the outside to be generally similar services to answer that. Assuming that they really are an innovative service, they would need to conduct and provide the studies supporting the validity of their innovative service.