Re:Newegg trial: Crypto legend takes the stand, goes for kno...
by surge on Monday November 25, 2013 @12:42PM
(#6795532)
What's sad is, and maybe lost on the jury, is it actually increases his credibility, he's so accomplished in his field those with the earned degrees said "we view you as a peer or recognize you as a pioneer of our field, just take the degree". He is so smart or dedicated he reached that status without going to a class. Usually that means you've gone above and beyond what a traditional student has accomplished.
Re:Newegg trial: Crypto legend takes the stand, goes for kno...
by SkyMarshal on Monday November 25, 2013 @01:57PM
(#6796093)
Maybe a missed opportunity, but using Bill Gates as a counter-example of the necessity of formal education in CS could have neutralized that line of attack.
Re:Newegg trial: Crypto legend takes the stand, goes for kno...
by cynwoody on Monday November 25, 2013 @05:54PM
(#6797693)
And Steve Jobs. The two dominant companies in personal computing, both founded by drop-outs!
Re:Newegg trial: Crypto legend takes the stand, goes for kno...
by tomrod on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @01:37AM
(#6799549)
Just out of curiosity, how much trouble would he be in if he'd answered:
"I never had a full-time academic job, no, but have consulted with a number of PhD students as a knowledge resource in cryptography."
Is overanswering a bad thing in a court setting? It seems like lawyers always fish for information they can slant; full disclosure on a topic would seem to correct that failing?
Re:Newegg trial: Crypto legend takes the stand, goes for kno...
by ryansan on Monday November 25, 2013 @12:16PM
(#6795335)
Make sure you read the discussions below on the validity of using ad hominem arguments to undermine witness credibility. Hard to watch/read when the witness in question is an idol of yours, but still a valid approach in the court room.
That's not what Fenster did. He went on the attack.
"You never completed a master's degree, correct?" he asked Diffie.
"That's correct," said Diffie.
"Other than the honorary degree, you don't have an earned doctorate or Ph.D. correct?"
"That is correct," said Diffie.
And even though he taught a few courses, "you never had a real professorship, correct?" asked Fenster.
"I never had a full-time academic job, no."