I'm ashamed to say that I said "in some sense" to be deliberately vague about what I meant by consistency - I didn't want to overstate the strength of Cox's theorem or end up arguing about Godel.
Re:How to share data with a statistician
by loup-vaillant on Monday November 25, 2013 @06:15PM
(#6797780)
Actually, I was accusing you of understating the strength of Cox's theorem.
Re:How to share data with a statistician
by thebooktocome on Monday November 25, 2013 @11:00AM
(#6794760)
> Are you seriously suggesting that the assumptions behind Cox's Theorem can reasonably be challenged?
Sure: probability is continuous.
Re:How to share data with a statistician
by loup-vaillant on Monday November 25, 2013 @06:13PM
(#6797773)
You mean, "it is not totally obvious that probability is continuous".
Well… To me, it is obvious.
Also, the Frequentist approach is not wrong. It's inaccurate, to the extent its results differ from the Bayesian ones. This inaccuracy tend to go down as we gather more data. Which is a good thing, or else science itself wouldn't work.
One more thing. You said "in some sense". Are you seriously suggesting that the assumptions behind Cox's Theorem can reasonably be challenged?