But in this specific case, seems FDA isn't being totally unreasonable. For example, from the letter
"Thus, months after you submitted your 510(k)s and more than 5 years after you began marketing, you still had not completed some of the studies and had not even started other studies necessary to support a marketing submission for the PGS"
seems like a good idea to require companies to do this
So either the government ensures the above or it does not get accomplished? There are no third parties that could take this on? I find that hard to believe.
In fact, I would venture they are worse because they have to be paid somehow, and if they are paid by industry, you are ripe for regulatory capture. It can be difficult to get consumers to pay for it unless you include some kind of tax in the product they buy in which case you've arrived at a pseudo-government agency.
Look how smallpox vaccine was discovered. Edward Jenner inoculated a young boy with cow pox, then attempted to infect him with smallpox a dozen times. Obviously we can't go around convincing young children to take infectious doses of deadly viruses. But we also cant send FDA thugs after every Silicon Valley startup pushing the boundaries of genomics research. So where do we draw the line?