Re:Aldous Huxley: the prophet of our brave new digital dystopia
by eli_gottlieb on Sunday November 24, 2013 @10:14AM
(#6789757)
The problem is that the definition of freedom has some assumptions most of Enlightenment philosophy (being so bizarrely focused around thought experiments dealing with yeoman farmers on homesteads) has direly neglected, namely: relationships with other people.
What is freedom? Freedom, we're told, is when you can make decisions for yourself. Therefore, are we in servitude to the laws of physics? Well no, those are impersonal. Yet are we told that we can be in servitude by force, by deprivation, or even by manipulation of our own desires? Yes.
So what's freedom? Freedom really means having our own actions unconstrained by the values or goals of other people (for a large value of "people", including institutions, the State, and in the limit God Himself). There the problem emerges: the only way to be completely unconstrained by other people, to be totally free, is to have no actual relations with other people whatsoever.
Total freedom, therefore, is total isolation, but this fact is never acknowledged because so much of our philosophical tradition assumes that freedom proceeds from the individual alone and precedes social relationships entirely. It assumes that everyone is a yeoman farmer on a plot of land who should always be able to retreat to his property and do exactly as he pleases -- which never happens in real life.
Then, are people really so stupid for choosing "less freedom", or are they just finding more meaning in the presence of voluntary relationships than the absence of compulsory ones?
What is freedom? Freedom, we're told, is when you can make decisions for yourself. Therefore, are we in servitude to the laws of physics? Well no, those are impersonal. Yet are we told that we can be in servitude by force, by deprivation, or even by manipulation of our own desires? Yes.
So what's freedom? Freedom really means having our own actions unconstrained by the values or goals of other people (for a large value of "people", including institutions, the State, and in the limit God Himself). There the problem emerges: the only way to be completely unconstrained by other people, to be totally free, is to have no actual relations with other people whatsoever.
Total freedom, therefore, is total isolation, but this fact is never acknowledged because so much of our philosophical tradition assumes that freedom proceeds from the individual alone and precedes social relationships entirely. It assumes that everyone is a yeoman farmer on a plot of land who should always be able to retreat to his property and do exactly as he pleases -- which never happens in real life.
Then, are people really so stupid for choosing "less freedom", or are they just finding more meaning in the presence of voluntary relationships than the absence of compulsory ones?