Re:Design: Voting up or Down is Dead
by waleedka on Sunday October 14, 2007 @10:53PM
(#67872)
By doing so, you make the UI complex. Only a small percentage of people vote in social news sites as it is, even with the simple one-click up/down.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I've designed it so that the user doesn't see the voting option for importance until after they've voted for the accuracy of the quote.
I'm not sure this fixes it. Try to factor the human emotional side into the equation. For example, for an article that says "RoR sucks", what do you think Ruby enthusiasts will vote? Even if it's accurate, they'll still mark it as inaccurate, because they'd be hating it and wouldn't want it to go up on the home page. It's human nature.