Re:Sudden Progress on Prime Number Problem Has Mathematician...
by mikeash on Saturday November 23, 2013 @02:13PM
(#6787059)
I don't know if athletes are really a good model to follow here.
If intelligent people were treated like athletes, some would indeed benefit enormously. But it's not all roses. That "rat race" is still there. Intelligent people would be using their smarts to get money for education (just like now!) but the relationship would become much more exploitative, with the schools potentially making millions off of them without the student seeing any of that.
Afterwards, a small number of the most intelligent would have a shot at making millions, with most never making it, with most either having to find careers elsewhere, and the lucky ones leading unglorious lives in small towns making little money, always hoping to make it big but seeing that chance fade year after year.
Even those who are good enough to make millions have it thrust upon them with almost no preparation, as they get massive contracts based on their potential. Most of them, despite being intelligent, are not good with money and end up squandering their wealth.
And of course none of them are able to keep their positions for a very long time, since it's a young man's thing. They get ejected, used and abused and still fairly young, and if they haven't managed their money well then they are also broke.
Not that I'd at all mind being in Michael Jordan's position, but my point is that those are the exception rather than the rule, and despite the overall high regard for them, trying to be a professional athlete is not generally a particularly great proposition. Compared to academia, where you generally expect to reach a position where you'll have a good income until you die, or if you fail in academia you at least have useful skills that people will pay you for in the outside world, the world of sports seems downright cruel.
If intelligent people were treated like athletes, some would indeed benefit enormously. But it's not all roses. That "rat race" is still there. Intelligent people would be using their smarts to get money for education (just like now!) but the relationship would become much more exploitative, with the schools potentially making millions off of them without the student seeing any of that.
Afterwards, a small number of the most intelligent would have a shot at making millions, with most never making it, with most either having to find careers elsewhere, and the lucky ones leading unglorious lives in small towns making little money, always hoping to make it big but seeing that chance fade year after year.
Even those who are good enough to make millions have it thrust upon them with almost no preparation, as they get massive contracts based on their potential. Most of them, despite being intelligent, are not good with money and end up squandering their wealth.
And of course none of them are able to keep their positions for a very long time, since it's a young man's thing. They get ejected, used and abused and still fairly young, and if they haven't managed their money well then they are also broke.
Not that I'd at all mind being in Michael Jordan's position, but my point is that those are the exception rather than the rule, and despite the overall high regard for them, trying to be a professional athlete is not generally a particularly great proposition. Compared to academia, where you generally expect to reach a position where you'll have a good income until you die, or if you fail in academia you at least have useful skills that people will pay you for in the outside world, the world of sports seems downright cruel.