News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Aldous Huxley: the prophet of our brave new digital dystopia by PhasmaFelis on Saturday November 23, 2013 @02:04PM (#6787016)
Brave New World is a nasty reactionary's idea of dystopia. There are genuine horrors there--conditioning, eugenics, erasure of independent thought--but the central themes that it keeps coming back to are that everybody's employed, everybody's happy, nobody's hungry or sick or miserable, there's safe, consequence-free, recreational sex and drugs for everyone, and these are portrayed as bad things.

BNW is fucked up in some serious ways, but--taken as an average across all levels of society--I think it's actually better than the world we live in now.

Huxley, to his credit, eventually came around to the idea that sex, drugs, and communal living could be used for good as well as evil, and actually wrote a utopian response to his own earlier dystopian work. It's telling that Brave New World remains in every high school curriculum, but no one's ever heard of Island. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Island_(Huxley_novel)

Re:Aldous Huxley: the prophet of our brave new digital dystopia by dntrkv on Saturday November 23, 2013 @03:54PM (#6787384)
It's not that those things are bad, it's the way they are used by the society.

The drugs are used to avoid confrontation, emotional hurt, and to keep people content with the status quo.

Everybody is employed... Yes, but they are conditioned to be content with their class and job in society. You can't move up or down in class, you are born into your job.

Nobody is hungry because everyone gets enough to survive, but only because everybody is conditioned to enjoy their jobs and be content with their place in society.

Sex is treated in the exact opposite manner of what we have now, sex is only used for recreation and encouraged (even forced) from a young age.

I don't see how you can view any of these ideas as being "good." I would trade our fucked up world over what they have in Brave New World any time.

Re:Aldous Huxley: the prophet of our brave new digital dystopia by PhasmaFelis on Sunday November 24, 2013 @04:19AM (#6789197)
> I would trade our fucked up world over what they have in Brave New World any time.

That's certainly a valid opinion. Still, I suspect it's easier to see BNW as an utter horrorshow if you've never known real hunger or oppression or torture or watched loved ones die of treatable diseases. I'm in the same boat myself. But there are many millions of people in our world who would be genuinely much better off in the Brave New World. It's hard to know what to think about that.

Re:Aldous Huxley: the prophet of our brave new digital dystopia by ahomescu1 on Sunday November 24, 2013 @04:18PM (#6791173)
> Everybody is employed... Yes, but they are conditioned to be content with their class and job in society.

I'm not sure that's a downside. The opposite is that people would only be content if they're at the top (CEO/rockstar/movie star/billionarie), creating a rat race. That's at least as harmful as BNW, if not more.

Re:Aldous Huxley: the prophet of our brave new digital dystopia by eli_gottlieb on Saturday November 23, 2013 @05:47PM (#6787752)
True, but also kind of missing the point.

Basically, what kind of person has such a petty, nasty view of the human species that he honestly believes, if left to our own devices, we'll turn into that?

When you read Brave New World in high school it's a little difficult to recognize there's multiple layers of satire there.

Re:Aldous Huxley: the prophet of our brave new digital dystopia by notahacker on Saturday November 23, 2013 @04:55PM (#6787597)
There was a reason why Huxley picked an insecure religious fundamentalist with a fondness for self-flagellation and fear of his own sexuality to contrast with the Brave New World. And it wasn't because he identified with him.

The satire is of the relentless drive towards excess, which Huxley saw epitomised in America's nascent consumerist culture and the drive to industrialization it was serving. The reason why it keeps coming back to the relentless sex and drugs isn't because Huxley then thought sex and drugs were bad, it's because he though any sane authoritarian regime would give the people the distractions they wanted most.

Re:Aldous Huxley: the prophet of our brave new digital dystopia by RodericDay on Saturday November 23, 2013 @02:10PM (#6787052)
I don't think it's that 'telling'. I'm a big fan of Huxley and I realize what he tried to do, but BNW is frankly a much better novel than The Island.  On another note, The Machine Stops and The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas are also pretty good.
Re:Aldous Huxley: the prophet of our brave new digital dystopia by emn13 on Saturday November 23, 2013 @05:49PM (#6787787)
I think your overthinking things here. Who's portraying them as bad things? I think the point isn't that they're bad, it's that they're used by a society to keep itself in a coma.

A society that has killed itself isn't a good thing, but what you read into that is your own perspective. You see happiness as being the problem itself here; but you might also see the means of pursuit as being problematic. Or you might see that happiness may be an insufficient precondition for a healthy society. Or an indictment of mankind in that we're a literally happy to sell our souls for contentment. Or that we don't value the ability to make up our own minds enough.

In short: it's thought provoking, and by all means draw your own conclusions - but even if you think that a happy society is necessarily good and that huxley's full of it, maybe there's still something in another perspective.

For example, it reminds me of how when you optimize for a particular benchmark, you may well succeed while losing sight of the big picture; and you might end up doing more harm than good.

Re:Aldous Huxley: the prophet of our brave new digital dystopia by terhechte on Saturday November 23, 2013 @02:42PM (#6787172)
I'm ashamed to say that this is the first time I heard about island. Sounds intriguing, I just ordered the book. Thanks!
Re:Aldous Huxley: the prophet of our brave new digital dystopia by eli_gottlieb on Saturday November 23, 2013 @06:18PM (#6787868)
It is probably the only completely untarnished utopia in all of literature. Or possibly one of the only, and I simply haven't heard of a few of the rest. I'm told Le Guin's The Dispossessed deals with similar issues.

Certainly it's one of the only cases where, if someone said they were buying real-estate there, I wouldn't actually look at them funny.

Re:Aldous Huxley: the prophet of our brave new digital dystopia by phaus on Saturday November 23, 2013 @05:06PM (#6787631)
While I feel that every student should read a Brave New World, it is not included in every high school cirriculum. In the US at least, it is actually pretty rare for a school to include it.
Re:Aldous Huxley: the prophet of our brave new digital dystopia by rayiner on Saturday November 23, 2013 @03:37PM (#6787333)
Devastating response to the article.

I loved BNW when I went through my libertarian phase in college too.

Re:Aldous Huxley: the prophet of our brave new digital dystopia by enraged_camel on Saturday November 23, 2013 @04:30PM (#6787528)
I don't think BNW has anything to do with libertarianism. I read it to be primarily a criticism of Western apathy. People in BNW are so obsessed with their empty lives, chasing pleasure after pleasure, that they are completely uninterested in (and therefore removed from) the big picture. They are basically animals, and are governed and manipulated as such.
Re:Aldous Huxley: the prophet of our brave new digital dystopia by eli_gottlieb on Saturday November 23, 2013 @05:45PM (#6787747)
The problem being that talking about the Bigger Picture gets people mad at you for being preachy, and even leads to holy wars.
Re:Aldous Huxley: the prophet of our brave new digital dystopia by geden on Saturday November 23, 2013 @06:22PM (#6787878)
Island is amazing. I wish I had one of it's parrots.