News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by josephagoss on Saturday November 23, 2013 @12:31PM (#6786661)
Please stop with the privacy scaremongering. A lot of work is currently going into trustless mixing/anonymising services that will largely stop this type of tracking. (coinjoin/zerocoin)

A lot of us are investing with the expectation true anonymous transactions eventually happen, because when they do Bitcoin will become even more valuable.

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by mikeash on Saturday November 23, 2013 @02:36PM (#6787155)
People are supposed to stop stating true facts because people are doing research that everybody hopes will solve the problem?

That's... pretty stupid.

Calling it "privacy scaremongering" would be reasonable if it were simply wrong. But if it's completely correct, and the only reason you disagree is because you're pretty sure it'll eventually be solved, that's crazy.

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by shock-value on Saturday November 23, 2013 @12:56PM (#6786757)
cheez is hardly scaremongering. As it stands truly anonymous and private transactions on Bitcoin are apparently impossible. (I'm not a Bitcoin user so feel free to correct me.) I would say that you are the one who is doing whatever the opposite of scaremongering would be called (hope-mongering?).
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by fragsworth on Saturday November 23, 2013 @01:33PM (#6786894)
> As it stands truly anonymous and private transactions on Bitcoin are apparently impossible.

Not true. There are many, many schemes that can be built into the protocol or on top of it to make transactions anonymous. Rather than hastily choosing one, it's probably better to wait for a really good scheme to surface.

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=241.0

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by fhars on Saturday November 23, 2013 @02:55PM (#6787213)
If we have to wait for a scheme to surface, that does maen that as it stands truly anonymous and private transactions on Bitcoin are currently impossible, right?
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by danneu on Saturday November 23, 2013 @05:42PM (#6787738)
Right now, you and I and our friends could sign our transactions so that nobody can tell which outputs correspond to which inputs. What's missing is that it's not widely distributed in a major client where everyone will partake by default.

Until then, it's opt-in, a hassle, with a small pool of anonymity. But "impossible" isn't the word I'd use to describe the scenario.

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by cenhyperion on Saturday November 23, 2013 @03:13PM (#6787260)
>There are many, many schemes that can be built into the protocol or on top of it to make transactions anonymous.

So as it stands truly anonymous transactions are impossible. The possibility to make that not true doesn't negate the fact that today bitcoin is in no way a private way of transferring money.

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by DanBC on Saturday November 23, 2013 @12:58PM (#6786766)
> anonymous and private transactions

Something doesn't have to be private to be anonymous. So if you're happy with anonymous and public it's possible, but hard.

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by shock-value on Saturday November 23, 2013 @01:04PM (#6786787)
In theory yes, but as the linked blog-post shows, Bitcoin---in its current state anyway---likely isn't truly anonymous either (ostensibly due to its transactional records being public).
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by tracker1 on Saturday November 23, 2013 @03:26PM (#6787300)
If you create a new wallet.. coins sent to that wallet, a person may know where the coins came from (because of other transactions to their wallet), they don't know for certain that the new wallet is you..

In the case of the article, the reason it's suspected, not even confirmed, is simply because the number of wallets coins were coming from were identified as the same source.

It's definitely more anonymous than wire transfers, or credit card transactions. The way to avoid detection would be to keep many, relatively small wallets... and disperse money from different sources fairly evently.

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by dllthomas on Saturday November 23, 2013 @05:19PM (#6787669)
Yeah, my gauge reads "more anonymous than wire transfers or credit cards, less anonymous than cash". Hard to send cash digitally, though.
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by kaoD on Monday November 25, 2013 @10:53AM (#6794704)
Then it's just not-private, but still anonymous (I don't need to disclose my name to get a Bitcoin address).
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by gnaritas on Saturday November 23, 2013 @12:56PM (#6786755)
> A lot of work is currently going into trustless mixing/anonymising

Call it what it is, money laundering.

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by fexl on Saturday November 23, 2013 @01:53PM (#6786963)
The term "money laundering" originally referred to the practice of concealing the movement of funds involved in a crime. Now they've redefined it so that concealing the movement of funds is itself a crime, even if the funds are entirely legitimate and no other crime is involved.
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by nl on Sunday November 24, 2013 @03:55AM (#6789139)
Actually, it hasn't been redefined at all - at least legally.

To quote Wikipedia:

It is defined as knowingly engaging in a financial transaction with the proceeds of a crime for the purpose of concealing or disguising the illicit origin of the property from governments.[1]

More specifically, money laundering is defined in Article 6.1.a.i and 6.1.a.ii of the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime[2]. The PDF won't let me copy & paste the text, but it uses the language "proceeds of crime" in both subsections.

Some jurisdictions may have monetary reporting laws which are broken during transferring BTCs, but it isn't money laundering (under international law anyway).

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money_laundering#Criminalizing_...

[2] http://www.unodc.org/documents/treaties/UNTOC/Publications/T...

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by consonants on Saturday November 23, 2013 @02:36PM (#6787148)
Yes, because the motivations behind money laundering are driven almost exclusively by crime. For purchases you wish to remain private, such as personally embarrassing products, there are 'anonymizing' but traceable services for you to save face with.

There are very few legitimate reasons to be concealing where you money came from or is going from the IRS, and they well aware of the intent behind the actions.

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by Amadou on Saturday November 23, 2013 @03:14PM (#6787265)
The problem isn't the IRS, it is everybody else who wants to know. Especially in the case of bitcoin where all transactions are public record.

Come up with a way for the IRS to investigate (not just get it handed to them on a platter, but something that mathematically requires a level of effort to prevent fishing expeditions by IRS employees) while simultaneously keeping all transactions private from everyone else and then we'll have a solution.

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by nazgulnarsil on Saturday November 23, 2013 @05:03PM (#6787622)
>There are very few legitimate reasons to be concealing where you money came from or is going from the IRS, and they well aware of the intent behind the actions

Nice circular reasoning. Because everything that the IRS would disapprove of is illegitimate? When did the IRS get ultimate moral authority?

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by superuser2 on Saturday November 23, 2013 @05:28PM (#6787690)
IRS doesn't care what the money is from or for, only that Uncle Sam gets what he's owed. Income from criminal enterprises is not special: you have to pay taxes on it like everything else. The source of the income is kind of don't-ask-don't-tell.

Spending on sex toys is not special, unless the national security apparatus (or more likely your competitor in the private sector) already has a reason to try to discredit you. Which is a valid concern for activists, but not most people.

Investigations and enforcement actions by the IRS have nothing to do with the morality of your checking account statement and everything to do with tax evasion.

The largest threat to your financial privacy is private enterprise. Underwriters, prospective employers, and others with a financial stake in your "good behavior" are the most interested in judging the moral acceptability/health/prudence of your financial choices.

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by exo762 on Sunday November 24, 2013 @05:29AM (#6789270)
> Spending on sex toys is not special, unless the national security apparatus (or more likely your competitor in the private sector) already has a reason to try to discredit you. Which is a valid concern for activists, but not most people.

Amazing.

Translation: "Rights are essential for small group of people, because everyone else is not exercising them anyway. So lets just take the rights away".

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by superuser2 on Sunday November 24, 2013 @04:05PM (#6791124)
From where do you derive a right to hide your finances from a government whose power to levy an income tax is explicitly codified in the Constitution?
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by exo762 on Friday December 06, 2013 @07:53AM (#6860817)
1) Bitcoin is incredibly more transparent than banking system or tax system. If anything, it is not convenient for tax evaders. HSBC, however, managed to launder 200bln of drug money.

2) I'm a person. I have to pay taxes. Top500 corps - not so much, in practice. What do you say about that?

3) Where the fuck did you get that I'm a tax evader? I was addressing your point about people's rights and your evaluation of their need of having those rights.

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by mindcrime on Saturday November 23, 2013 @08:48PM (#6788301)
There are very few legitimate reasons to be concealing where you money came from or is going from the IRS

That's irrelevant. I don't need a reason for concealing where my money comes from.

Oh sure, the IRS may disagree, but I have a really hard time giving a shit about what the IRS thinks.

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by PeterisP on Sunday November 24, 2013 @03:48AM (#6789133)
Well, you may ignore IRS but it doesn't mean that IRS will ignore you; and it is perfectly able to take your stuff and liberty even if you don't give a shit about what they think.
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by fexl on Sunday November 24, 2013 @09:02AM (#6789622)
Point taken, but in spite of their aspirations, they are neither omniscient nor omnipotent. Thank goodness.
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by fexl on Saturday November 23, 2013 @04:32PM (#6787535)
I make sure Uncle Soprano gets his cut.
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by algorias on Saturday November 23, 2013 @01:44PM (#6786927)
It may be, depending on your definition, but the term "money laundering" has a distinctly criminal connotation. Bitcoin mixing is more analogous to paying for something with cash withdrawn from a bank account rather than making a bank transfer directly.
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by consonants on Saturday November 23, 2013 @02:29PM (#6787123)
Money laundering is the process of concealing sources of money. If the IRS found out Western Union was trying to cover it's tracks of who sent/received money they would be investigated immediately. Laundering implies you have something to hide, most likely tax dollars or ill-received profits.
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by bobwaycott on Sunday November 24, 2013 @01:40AM (#6788935)
Money laundering is the process of concealing illegal sources of money.
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by VMG on Saturday November 23, 2013 @01:10PM (#6786806)
It isn't.
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by hbags on Saturday November 23, 2013 @01:29PM (#6786878)
A mixer's sole purpose in life is collect a fee for concealing sources of money. It's textbook money laundering.
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by VMG on Saturday November 23, 2013 @04:13PM (#6787456)
Except with Bitcoin, there are valid reasons to conceal the source and destination of money from the public besides criminal activity. The money being "laundered" isn't necessarily "dirty" to begin with.

The same logic applies to encryption. People have a right to privacy.

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by PeterisP on Sunday November 24, 2013 @03:50AM (#6789134)
There can be (and are) regulations that may (in particular circumstances) make illegal to conceal the source and destination of money transfers even if the money is clean.

People don't have an absolute right of privacy - the laws can and do restrict that.

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by gnaritas on Saturday November 23, 2013 @09:12PM (#6788363)
It doesn't matter what the reasons are, or whether you have a right to it, if you're trying to conceal where money came from, it's money laundering.
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by bobwaycott on Sunday November 24, 2013 @01:49AM (#6788950)
Only if that money is the proceeds of a crime and you're attempting to conceal the source of the illegal funds.

The flippant and universalizing way several of the commenters here are referring to money laundering as "concealing where the money came from" cast far too wide a net.

The definition you're using here would include concealing where $500 came from that was donated by anonymous friends to give to another friend in need. Suddenly, by your metric, if any of the friends suspected of donating the cash to help someone don't fess up to the source of the cash, they're laundering money.

Yeah, that's ridiculous. But it fits your description. Money laundering requires the currency be earnings from criminal activity.

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by PeterisP on Sunday November 24, 2013 @03:59AM (#6789146)
If you're running a coin mixing service that makes the coins anonymous to others then as soon as a single transaction is true money laundering (from criminal activity), then you're liable for that. If a single Fed sting operation on silkroad buys drugs for some bitcoin that afterwards gets to your service - you're going down.

Pretty much the only way to do so 'properly' would require you to make the coins anonymous to the public, but ID all of your customers and keep records on who actually gets which coins in the end.

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by bobwaycott on Sunday November 24, 2013 @02:53PM (#6790825)
Like the other commenter, you're speaking to a different angle. I was commenting strictly on the repeated blanket statements made throughout these comments that any concealing of the source of money == money laundering. I was not speaking to liability ramifications of running a coin mixing service at all. I wasn't even contending that there might not be legitimate claims made against bitcoin activity that could be money laundering. The act of concealing where money came from as a general principle is not itself money laundering. Yes, running a service that facilitates concealing the source of money can quickly become a target and risk liability for laundering activities. That is still, however, an entirely different point.
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by hbags on Sunday November 24, 2013 @08:45AM (#6789588)
Put your money where your mouth is. Openly run a mixer. Openly advertise that you are the person who operates it.

If you're right and I'm wrong, it'll be a lucrative business and you'll probably quickly dominate the mixer industry, as it'd be very easy for you to get press and build name recognition. You could do it as a very part-time job.

If I'm right and you're wrong, you'll be in prison.

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by bobwaycott on Sunday November 24, 2013 @02:48PM (#6790800)
You're not responding to the point I wrote, or the parent comment to which I replied.
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by baddox on Saturday November 23, 2013 @06:56PM (#6787982)
It's both. There is such a thing as synonyms.
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by cheez on Saturday November 23, 2013 @12:54PM (#6786744)
It's not scaremongering. Can you trust the mixing services?
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by tedunangst on Saturday November 23, 2013 @02:23PM (#6787095)
The more mixing is done, the higher the daily bitcoin transaction volume is, and the more trustworthy bitcoin becomes!
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by salient on Saturday November 23, 2013 @12:56PM (#6786756)
The question is will the Bitcoin Foundation put those add-ons into the Bitcoin protocol? I think they would be quite reluctant to do it at this point, as they are more concerned with establishing Bitcoin as a viable currency right now, that's not used just by Silk Road and its ilk.

I do think in the mid to long term Zerocoin or something similar should be added to Bitcoin to at least allow people the option to be anonymous if they want to be.

However, I'm also unsure if this should be done right now as governments are trying to decide what to do with Bitcoin. Perhaps it would be better to wait a couple more years, get Bitcoin more established into the mainstream, and adopted by banks and more companies, and then enable something like Zerocoin in the protocol, when it would be too late to stop Bitcoin. Although I'm not sure what the government's reaction towards Zerocoin would be then.

On the other hand, Bitcoin may be even harder to kill than file-sharing/torrenting, in which case maybe it won't matter if it's done now, as the government's action against it could be irrelevant.

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by anigbrowl on Saturday November 23, 2013 @03:04PM (#6787240)
You're not investing. You're speculating - a perfectly valid use of your own money, but different nonetheless.
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by chm on Saturday November 23, 2013 @03:15PM (#6787269)
Any investment is speculation until proven otherwise. And by that I mean that "the mass" accepts it as an "investment".
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by anigbrowl on Sunday November 24, 2013 @06:27PM (#6791660)
I'm distinguishing it from investments that pay a dividend or interest coupon at time of purchase, or which have a commodity value independent of price (eg gold and oil are commodities that you can speculate in or take delivery of for actual consumption).

You might well get rich from speculating in bitcoin, but if if doesn't pan out then your assets could end up having no value whatsoever - you won't even be able to burn them to keep warm during the zombie apocalypse ;)

I'm not trying to comment on the viability of BTC here, just pointing out that it not the same as many other asset classes.

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by chm on Sunday November 24, 2013 @11:33PM (#6792497)
Then we agree that it is a very risky investment and one should be careful about it =)
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by PeterisP on Sunday November 24, 2013 @03:41AM (#6789123)
Can any of the mixing/anonymising services hide the fact that a mixing/anonymising service was used?

It's trivial to work against them - simply forbid any legal business offering goods, services or bitcoin-currency transactions to accept such coins. In essence, the same way that they're fighting right now against laundered cash - you can do it, but not on large scale, and it's not accepted for most of assets you want to buy.

Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by dllthomas on Saturday November 23, 2013 @05:15PM (#6787653)
You mean trustless mixing/anonymising services that will largely get you brought up on money-laundering charges.
Re:Here’s who probably did that $150 million Bitcoin transac... by consonants on Saturday November 23, 2013 @02:28PM (#6787116)
Please stop interjecting with your vested interest as if it trumps anyone else's valid concerns.