As a professional photographer (and programmer), I can easily answer that: because they are professionals, and they want to get paid for THEIR pictures.
How about someone steals your business' source code (which you didn't release as FOSS)? Why shouldn't he? Because you spent a couple thousand dollars on a laptop? (if I'm allowed to to use your reasoning).
Not to mention: it's not just the camera: it's also their being were they need to take the pictures (which has costs), they risks they went through, years of training etc. And their particular expression (composition, etc).
If you think their pictures are not worth what they ask for, then don't use them. If you think they are worth it, pay for them. It's that simple.
>I've been a professional photographer for over 10 years, and it makes me sick how paranoid others in the industry are.
Well, if you're a wedding photographer, or a fine art photographer that makes his living from selling framed, signed and numbered prints, you don't qualify.
In the article we're talking about people that make their money from selling their pictures for print and online media and such (photojournalists). Though it also applies the same to stock photographers.
>The balance of power is completely wrong, and photographers, musical artists, and other "creatives"
If you want to take their stuff and listen to it or use it on the front page of your newspaper then they are clearly creative -- and the quotation marks around that word are not helping your comment.
>If proper attribution is given to the creator (same as quoting what someone says) then photographs should be shared.
Thanks for pissing all over my profession.
To answer your idea: people in general don't say things as a business to make money. That's why they are quoted for free. Were "quote" also means "a small part of what they said".
Those that do say things to get paid (e.g comedians, writers, journalists etc), don't get their words reprinted for free.
Not a proper analogy. You don't sell software because of source code, you sell it based on what users see. Sharing photographs (with proper attribution) is free marketing.
>[...] you don't qualify.
Why not? I'm paid to press a button on a camera. My product is the same as yours.
>Thanks for pissing all over my profession.
Why? Because I disagree with the prevailing view that photographs are sacred objects that should be locked in a vault available only to those who pay for them?
Yes, I get annoyed when I see my photos elsewhere used without permission/attribution. But have I lost money because of it? I've gained much more business by trying to see that my photos are seen by as many people as possible.
Your arguments are one in the same as the ones used by the RIAA and MPAA. A stolen MP3 or photograph is not a direct negative sale.
Photography is similar to music, so I'll quote from the article 'Why Most Artists Profit from Piracy':
>Several studies have shown that most artists actually profit from unauthorized sharing of files. They sell more albums because people have the opportunity to download songs and entire albums for free. A study by Blackburn (2004), a PhD student from Harvard, found that the 75% of the artist actually profit from piracy. Blackburn reports that the most popular artist (top 25%) sell less records. However, the remaining 75% of all artists actually profit from filesharing.
Source: http://torrentfreak.com/why-most-artists-profit-from-piracy/
it can be, but that's a pretty large blanket statement. first, it's not free. it costs me something when a photo is used without an exchange of payment for a license to use that photo.
but even playing devil's advocate: marketing doesn't pay our mortgage. publicity doesn't put food on the table for my family.
:)
It's an investment. You do it in hopes that current work will yield a larger future gain, be it through experience, wisdom, exposure, or something else.
and there is the distinction: you are choosing to contribute. when a photo of mine is used without my consent, approval or of my choosing to have it be used, it has been stolen.
And not all people want fucking "free marketing" (ie. let me use your stuff for free, devaluing it as a salable item, and conpensate with "exposure"). That's like the oldest slimmest trick in the book anyway, from people who don't want to pay: and it amounts to "You should be thanking US for using your work".
>>[...] you don't qualify. Why not? I'm paid to press a button on a camera. My product is the same as yours.
No, if you're on one of those cases describes, then your business model is different.
>Why? Because I disagree with the prevailing view that photographs are sacred objects that should be locked in a vault available only to those who pay for them?
That's not the definition of "sacred object". That's the definition of something you sell. And yes, a photograph can be something one sells. If you want to give your photographs for free, have a blast. Others wish to sell theirs for use should be respected from people wanting to use them.
>Yes, I get annoyed when I see my photos elsewhere used without permission/attribution. But have I lost money because of it? I've gained much more business by trying to see that my photos are seen by as many people as possible.
That's your choice and more power to you. I, and others, don't want and don't value business and "exposure" gained by such use. That should be my choice.
>Your arguments are one in the same as the ones used by the RIAA and MPAA.
So what? I don't disagree with all of their arguments. It's 2013. We don't only sell tables and cars, we also sell intagible objects like intellectual property. We've been doing it for centuries. Easy zero-cost copying doesn't mean you can't have an economy of intangibles.
I'm only against part of the current situation, like crazy long copyright times (should be way shorter), obvious patents (should only exist for non obvious inventions), etc.
>A stolen MP3 or photograph is not a direct negative sale.
Besides the point. I don't want unathorized use of my WORK, regardless of if it represents a lost sale or not.
>Blackburn reports that the most popular artist (top 25%) sell less records. However, the remaining 75% of all artists actually profit from filesharing.
Yay, a study published in Torrentfreak.
> The balance of power is completely wrong...
If I may get a little meta, the goal of copyright is to reward someone for sharing an idea while allowing those who consume the idea to turn around and share it themselves. Since one cannot truly "own" an idea, copyright uses the "expression" of the idea as a proxy, since (in theory) re-expressing the idea extracts an effort penalty. For example, if I read words you publish, I can't just republish your words without your agreement. I can however express your idea in my own words. I may choose to just pay you to use your expression if generating my own is too costly.Photographs and "news" reveal the weakness of using "expression" as a mechanism for judging whether copyright exists. If I email my next door neighbor and tell him "garbage pickup is on tuesday" and he emails the exact words to his neighbor, has he violated copyright, or is he reporting news? If I attach a photo of the garbage pickup schedule, have I violated copyright? If I attribute the schedule to the trash company am I compliant?
My point is that copyright is complex and imperfect, and finding the balance of power is very difficult.
Despite how it may appear in other comments I've made in this thread, I don't believe corporate entities are entitled to use a photographer's works for profit and without attribution.
This may seem contradictory, but that's because I have failed to make the proper distinction between sharing for personal use and using for profit.
Now, you may chose to charge money for your photos, share them for free, or some mix of both, but the choice is ultimately yours. A news article may not appropriate your photo for their purposes without your permission and license unless it fits one of the fair use exceptions to copyright law.
I've been a professional photographer for close to the same amount of time you have. We own and regularly use approximately $50,000 worth of equipment, and the cost of that and our living has to be amortized over the amount we can realistically expect to sell in the lifespan of that equipment. I have absolutely no interest in someone else making money off my investment unless I get my cut. At no time has free work (e.g., magazines using photos with attribution) ever profited us either directly or indirectly. I'm not saying it couldn't ever, but in our experience, free or discounted begets more demands of the same.
The difference is that you can copyright presentation, but you can't copyright an idea.
Once someone strings together enough words, however, you can't copy it either. That is, after all, why we don't photocopy novels when we want to read them.
Also if you spoke to a reporter I suppose that would be an implied consent to have your words used.
I'm not taking sides with this comment, just pointing out the flaw in your argument.
Sharing images without attribution is the same as plagiarism. Should journalists that plagiarise words be fined a million dollars? I don't know, maybe. But it's the same issue.
EDIT: I'm not referring to law, only common sense and what actually happens in the real world.
Actually, you are. Talking about plagiarizing and being fined and trying to use legal arguments, and then content you aren't referring to the law?
> How is using someone else's image and giving them appropriate attribution any different than retweeting what they say?
By using Twitter, you give explicitly permission to retweet.
> Quoting them in a blog post?
If someone says something, you are free to quote them.
> If they post the image in a public forum (the internet) it's the same as words said in public.
No, it's not. It's explicitly not because the internet is not the same thing as a public forum.
> Should journalists that plagiarise words be fined a million dollars? I don't know, maybe.
It depends on to what degree the plagiarizing occurred. But you can't say maybe and follow it up with the edit that you did.
But this is a sad day. I've been a professional photographer for over 10 years, and it makes me sick how paranoid others in the industry are.
Why is it OK to quote what someone said for a news article, but not use their photo with proper attribution? Because they spent a couple hundred dollars on a camera? Why is a picture some sacrosanct object but what someone says worthless? You're pressing a button on a camera and then pressing some buttons on a computer later.
The balance of power is completely wrong, and photographers, musical artists, and other "creatives" only shoot themselves in the foot by slathering watermarks, issuing crazy copyright notices, and using DRM on their photos/creative works.
If proper attribution is given to the creator (same as quoting what someone says) then photographs should be shared. Encouraging the sharing of photos I've taken for clients has only increased my business. It's better for society.