News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Programming Language Checklist by seanmcdirmid on Friday November 22, 2013 @08:28PM (#6784799)
As a researcher working on experimental PLs [1]...why not

[1] http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/people/smcdirm/liveprogr...

  You appear to be advocating a new:
  [ ] functional  [X] imperative  [X] object-oriented  [X] procedural [ ] stack-based
  [ ] "multi-paradigm"  [ ] lazy  [ ] eager  [X] statically-typed  [ ] dynamically-typed
  [ ] pure  [X] impure  [ ] non-hygienic  [ ] visual  [ ] beginner-friendly

  You appear to believe that:
  [X] Garbage collection is free                [X] Computers have infinite memory
  [ ] Nobody really needs:
     [ ] concurrency  [X] a REPL  [ ] debugger support  [ ] IDE support  [ ] I/O
     [ ] to interact with code not written in your language
  [X] Convincing programmers to adopt a new language will be easy
  [X] Convincing programmers to adopt a language-specific IDE will be easy
  [X] "Spooky action at a distance" makes programming more fun

  Unfortunately, your language (H -> has/ L -> lacks) :
  [H] comprehensible syntax  [L] semicolons  [H] significant whitespace  [L] macros
  [L] implicit type conversion  [L] explicit casting  [H] type inference
  [L] goto  [L] exceptions  [L] closures  [L] tail recursion  [L] coroutines
  [L] reflection  [H] subtyping  [H] multiple inheritance  [L] operator overloading
  [L] algebraic datatypes  [L] recursive types  [H] polymorphic types
  [H] covariant array typing  [L] monads  [L] dependent types
  [H] infix operators  [L] nested comments  [L] multi-line strings  [L] regexes
  [H] call-by-value  [L] call-by-name  [L] call-by-reference  [L] call-cc

  The following philosophical objections apply:
  [X] The most significant program written in your language isn't even its own compiler
  [X] No language spec
  [X] "The implementation is the spec"
     [X] The implementation is closed-source  [X] covered by patents  [X] not owned by you
  [?] Your type system is unsound  
  [X] ____________________________ takes exponential time
  [X] ____________________________ is known to be undecidable

  Your implementation has the following flaws:
  [X] CPUs do not work that way
  [X] RAM does not work that way
  [X] VMs do not work that way
  [X] Compilers do not work that way
  [X] Compilers cannot work that way
  [X] You require the compiler to be present at runtime
  [X] You require the language runtime to be present at compile-time
  [X] Dangerous behavior is only a warning
  [X] You don't seem to understand basic optimization techniques
  [X] You don't seem to understand basic systems programming

  Additionally, your marketing has the following problems:
  [X] Unsupported claims of increased productivity
  [X] Unsupported claims of greater "ease of use"
  [ ] Noone really believes that your language is faster than:
     [X] assembly  [X] C  [X] FORTRAN  [X] Java  [X] Ruby  [ ] Prolog
  [X] Rejection of orthodox programming-language theory without justification
  [X] Rejection of orthodox systems programming without justification
  [ ] Rejection of orthodox algorithmic theory without justification
  [X] Rejection of basic computer science without justification

  Taking the wider ecosystem into account, I would like to note that:
  [X] We already have an unsafe imperative language
  [X] We already have a safe imperative OO language

  In conclusion, this is what I think of you:
  [ ] You have some interesting ideas, but this won't fly.
  [ ] This is a bad language, and you should feel bad for inventing it.
  [ ] Programming in this language is an adequate punishment for inventing it.

There are no comments on this comment yet.