Re:That 60W-equivalent LED: What no one will tell you
by mjn on Friday November 22, 2013 @12:09PM
(#6782057)
Are there any studies on how effective each method is? It seems fairly complex, depending on how good the methods being dictated are, how price-sensitive consumers are (and how well-informed about what costs/saves money), costs of switching, in some cases economies of scale, etc.
The conventional wisdom here (Denmark) has been that a mixture of the two achieves best results: a high tax on energy to provide an across-the-board untargeted price incentive, plus specific targeted regulations aiming at cutting out the largest sources of inefficiency and encouraging economies of scale in more efficient technologies. So for example district heating is now mandatory if you're in an area where it's available (no furnaces in new construction), and this seems to have been quite effective in increasing its adoption, which in turn makes it easier to build efficient district-heating networks and cogenerating power plants, since there is a dense customer base.
Re:That 60W-equivalent LED: What no one will tell you
by tedunangst on Friday November 22, 2013 @02:16PM
(#6783050)
I don't know specifically. I do know that all of the "alternate fuel" tax credits are a giant scam. How does spraying kerosene on coal make it clean? No clue, but the government will pay you to do it if you say it's alternative.
Re:That 60W-equivalent LED: What no one will tell you
by gaadd33 on Sunday November 24, 2013 @07:46PM
(#6791892)
Couldn't it make it cleaner by promoting more complete combustion in power plants thereby reducing particulate emissions?
Re:That 60W-equivalent LED: What no one will tell you
by tedunangst on Sunday November 24, 2013 @08:12PM
(#6791981)
I suppose anything is possible. The point is it would be better for the government to mandate results (lower emissions, which can be measured) than methods (spray kerosene on coal and hope it does something useful).
Lots of people would agree with that or the point in general that financial penalties work better. Legislation should mandate results, not dictate methods.