Re:The truth about fracking? An oilfield engineer seeks to r...
by astrodust on Thursday November 21, 2013 @01:35PM
(#6776451)
"We pump an enormous volume of chemicals of a proprietary composition into the ground mixed with water, a commodity already in short supply, but don't worry, it's totally safe. We just said so."
Engineers, for all their successes, have a long history of getting things very, very wrong. Pumping unknown gunk into the ground at a depth that's theoretically too deep to ever return is a hypothesis, and one that we are now testing apparently. The consequences could be catastrophic.
Re:The truth about fracking? An oilfield engineer seeks to r...
by Gravityloss on Thursday November 21, 2013 @11:35AM
(#6775573)
Yes, I guess it could be problematic to find disinterested experts in any hot new business area, since most experts are getting their paycheck from it.
I have no deep knowledge about the issue and I hope that someone can point me wrong.
Re:The truth about fracking? An oilfield engineer seeks to r...
by bradleysmith on Thursday November 21, 2013 @04:58PM
(#6777824)
exactly right. The only people that intimately know the workings of reservoirs, and know the risks and pitfalls of the fracking and production process from field experience are almost always directly benefiting from increased oil production won by fracking. I'm sure there are some environmental professionals that have been around the oil patch long enough to know what's what, and I'd love to hear their take.
I am unabashedly on the fence on the matter. It is one of those things that the consequences are far more irreversible if one party is correct, and I always try to bear that in mind.
I work in oil & gas data, so I'm surrounded by a bias from people that both benefit from fracking, and also have intimate working knowledge of the process. In my limited experience, I have found the above statement to be true.
I always love to hear informed arguments against fracking, I just seem to hear fewer of them than those in support of it.
Thanks for the share, good read.