She released stuff with XL Recordings (a label that had multi-million selling artists even back in the nineties) and then signed with Columbia.
Independent used to be somebody in a small label, like 4AD. Nowadays, it's somebody releasing his songs himself or such.
Adele hasn't qualified as such for over 5 years...
Just because they're incredibly successful, doesn't make them not an independent label. Changing the definition of "indie" to exclude XL makes the claim that 'indies aren't successful' a simple tautology.
Perhaps, but has the benefit that it keeps the definition of "indie" as "not a big marketing and sales behemoth" intact.
And that's more to the essense of being "independent" than "doesn't belong to a major record label".
If we're to accept incredibly succesful, large selling artists, big marketing as "independent", then what does distinguish major and indie record labels? Simply that it's not a conglomerate?