News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by sdrinf on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @10:31AM (#6768545)
Honest question: under what circumstances would it be beneficial for my dishwasher to be "smart" at all, let alone be connected to the Internet?

If that isn't a demonstrative example, what specific devices _would_ be useful to have Internet connectivity, and in what specific ways?

Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by kens on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @11:01AM (#6768769)
There are a bunch of specific devices that I would really like to connect to the internet:

Irrigation system: I shouldn't need to punch buttons on a controller box outside in the rain.

Anything with a clock, e.g. microwave, thermostat: It should get the right time itself.

Pool heater: I should be able to control it from the house and check the temperature.

Barbecue: It should let me know if it was left on (like happened yesterday).

Freezer: It should let me know if the door is ajar, before everything thaws.

Alarm system: monitoring and control.

Stereo: should be able to control from my phone.

Washing machine: notification if I left wet clothes in it, or if it goes off balance and stops.

These are mostly available now, but not in an easy-to-use way. Home automation seems to be like the home computer industry in the 1970s: you have to really want to do it, you need to be a bit of a hacker, it costs a fair bit, and what you end up with is pretty primitive. I think there's a huge market for someone to solve home automation. What I want is when I buy an irrigation controller from Home Depot (for example), it "just works" as part of a home system.

Edit: A couple people asked why connect to the internet? I should be able to do these things remotely, e.g. from the office or my phone.

a_c_s mentions that the time tinkering could outweigh the benefit. That's kind of what I'm getting at with my 1970s home computer analogy - you could do e.g. word processing back then, but it wasn't worth the difficulty for most people. Now non-technical people can buy a computer at Best Buy and easily do word processing. Likewise, home automation needs to become something that is built in to products and "just works" by default, rather than something for hackers.

Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by Pxtl on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @12:43PM (#6769538)
Funny how the actual API we want on 90% of these devices is actually all pretty similar:

Read/write the on/off mode, and get text notifications with severity (Info/Warning/Emergency). This is not some nightmarishly complicated interface. I'm sure we can all visualize what a good cellphone app would look like.

It seems like the big hurdle with home automation is the lack of a standard server for all the client devices to connect to. The challenge will be getting these disparate appliance companies to sit down and agree to anything... that won't happen until a big player gets enough of them onboard to make it a "must-have" feature.

Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by a_c_s on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @12:00PM (#6769195)
Thanks for enumerating this.

However, for me, the amount of time 'saved' for tasks like this seems like it could easily be outweighed by having to spend even a minimal amount of time tinkering/debugging the setup of these devices.

Given that my phone sometimes forgets which wifi network to use, I can only imagine having to reconfigure my microwave, washing machine, stove/oven, dishwasher, stereo, etc. occasionally. If each device forgets the wifi network infrequently, like once every six months, that means 12 times a year I have to configure wifi one of my six smart devices. This amount of reconfiguration is more time/frustration/effort than would be saved by the kinds of notifications listed.

Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by evacuationdrill on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @03:34PM (#6770971)
I agree, but ideally they'd be wired in. Perhaps new homes at one point will have Ethernet ports behind your stove, microwave, etc.

It's interesting that you chose 6 months, because that's how often you have to change the time. :D

Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by arethuza on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @11:23AM (#6768918)
"It should let me know if it was left on"

That is my #1 use case for me - I would love to have some view of our home to tell me that I haven't left anything on when we go away for a few days.

Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by aestra on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @11:25AM (#6768931)
I once left the burner on for a few hours, it was so scary when I realized it.
Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by arethuza on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @11:59AM (#6769184)
I eventually found a solution to being neurotic about turning things off - when we go away I go round and take pictures on my phone of all the things I would worry about.

The interesting thing is that I never need to look at the pictures - the mere fact they exist is enough to keep my happy....

[My family do indeed think I am crazy]

Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by Glyptodon on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @11:32AM (#6768978)
I left an oven on overnight once. Not really dangerous, but felt really stupid.

Though to be fair there wasn't any visual notification of its state - the light is only on when it's preheating.

Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by jlgaddis on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @11:55AM (#6769164)
With the exception of perhaps your security system (which is already possible), why would any of these need Internet connectivity?

I can see them being WiFi-enabled and able to talk to each other and some type of centralized control system in the home, but why would that need to connect to the Internet?

Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by mcguire on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @12:56PM (#6769650)
IP is a universally supported networking protocol. The alternatives seem to be industry-specific or worse.
Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by SourPatch on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @11:47AM (#6769109)
Most of those are reasons to be connected to a home network, not "The Internet."
Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by dublinben on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @10:59AM (#6768758)
A smart dishwasher could be programmed to run at the point in the day when your solar hot water heater reaches a certain temperature, or when electricity prices reach a certain level.
Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by Pxtl on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @12:37PM (#6769486)
Dish-washer is actually one of the devices I'd most like to be internet connected. Unlike a washing machine, the dishwasher is a cleaning implement that's I always keep loaded and ready to go. Detergent in the dispenser, full of stuff to wash. So being able to activate it remotely is handy. Also, getting a message to my phone when it completes would be handy. Same with washers/dryers - notification that the cycle is over and user intervention is required would be handy.

Remote status information on my oven and smoke-detectors and furnace and water-heater and water-detectors, while expensive, would also be fantastic peace-of-mind for the worrywarts among us - at any moment you know if your house is flooded or burning or whatever.

Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by maxerickson on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @11:13AM (#6768864)
Remote temperature monitoring (and control). Current devices at least feel expensive, and they are generally some combination of arcane and crappy. I guess Nest is figuring this space out.

At a low enough price point, being able to turn off lights and stuff like that is great, especially if there isn't much setting up involved.

Lots of other things benefit from some sort of connectivity, being able to do data collection and monitoring over a network enables a much more passive approach (which I expect means more people will take advantage of the opportunity...).

Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by mcguire on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @12:51PM (#6769605)
"...under what circumstances would it be beneficial for my dishwasher to be "smart" at all..."

An alternative that I haven't seen mentioned, but is supported, for some appliances: Your electrical or water supply utility could tell your dishwasher to delay its cycle in order for the utility overall to better balance its load.

Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by pcunite on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @10:43AM (#6768638)
Send you a text when it is done or out of rinse aid. The text would actually go to your sibling so they can do their new chore.
Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by antimagic on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @11:48AM (#6769122)
Remote diagnostics. The technician should already more or less know what is wrong with your machine before leaving the depot, which means s/he will already have the right parts / tools to get it fixed.
Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by Symmetry on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @11:55AM (#6769167)
A whole lot of stuff related to this:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_grid

Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by steveklabnik on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @10:59AM (#6768759)
"Hey Steve, normally, it's not your turn to do the dishes, but I see that John is out of town this week. Better get on that!"
Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by krapp on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @11:41AM (#6769059)
"hey Steve, we see you've eaten Hamburger Helper and Kraft Macaroni and Cheese three times this week. Would you like to learn more about dating services in your area?"
Re:The scariest part about the Internet of Things by steveklabnik on Wednesday November 20, 2013 @02:59PM (#6770717)
Oh yeah, it could go really terribly too.