The companies that are offering me jobs with lower salary and equity are not public, have no viable exit strategy in the near future, and therefore their equity is virtually worthless. There's a potential that it will be worth the equity at my current company, but the likelihood of that is low. That makes the risk high, so in order for me to justify leaving my currently vesting/cashable stock on the table, you have to offer me something I can't get right now, whether that's a higher salary, more equity, or something else.
It's not entirely a money issue. If I really, really believe in your company or I really, really hate my current job, I could more easily be persuaded to leave my current job. I'm fairly content where I am, though, so that's hard.
Also, you say "… that's assuming your equity is actually worth anything" but doesn't that assumption also apply to the equity you're currently vesting?