Ranking all engineers in the department together would be more difficult. Managers have a hard enough time getting a read on the strength of their own people; getting them to agree on how their people rank against the other managers' people would take quite a bit of work, I imagine. But it would give a much better answer to the question of whom to let go first, and it wouldn't provide as much incentive to game the system.
And I agree with you that the ranking should explicitly emphasize how well each employee works with their teammates.
This is a stacked rating.
Couldnt you have stacked ranking with a criteria that rewards all involved for collaboration?
Yes, though it's tougher to measure. People generally know who the best mentors are, and who they can call when they need help with a tough problem. They also know the worst mentors, and the people who don't return calls. It's very hard measuring the people in the middle.
The problem with some implementations is that it awards people for individual contributions and only if you are above average. This drives people to avoid contributions to a team so they can focus on their own personal contribution and to not want to help colleagues because that would drive the mean up eroding the value of personal contributions.
Couldnt you have stacked ranking with a criteria that rewards all involved for collaboration?