Re:The Insanity of Our Food Policy
by shadowOfShadow on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @12:36AM
(#6759470)
Give poor people money to buy food, they will likely optimize in fat+ ways. Pay people to be healthy. The needy can be healthy. Put a floor under everyone and then progressively incentivize health.
Health is its own reward; paying people for healthy _outcomes_ == worse poverty for the chronically unhealthy, partially disabled, and (in the US) victims of the non-healthcare system.
Re:The Insanity of Our Food Policy
by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @08:12AM
(#6760904)
People need to eat every day. Give people cash, it goes for random things. Give people food stamp - at a minimum they have food. I'm guess you've never been hungry. The folks who invented food stamps were trying to reduce a real problem.
This kind of rent seeking should not surprise anyone. The market moves a lot more quickly than government. Today's reasonable policy is tomorrow's corporate welfare.
The lesson I take from this: other things being equal, err on the side of fewer programs and regulations instead of more. If you want to help the needy, it's better to use broad-based direct assistance (like food stamps or the EITC) than a more complicated program that singles out some sub-group like farmers.