News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Research: Cubicles Are the Absolute Worst by rayiner on Monday November 18, 2013 @04:02PM (#6756995)
Unsurprisingly, private offices score the best, by a huge margin. Right now, I've got a huge office to myself (separate from a two-person office next to me by an open passageway). It's super quiet because there are bookshelves full of books to absorb any noise, as well as thick 1970-era carpeting. It's the most productive place I've ever worked. I have no idea why tech companies would pay engineers gobs of money,[1] spend gobs of money on huge office campuses,[2] then inflict open plan or cubicles on said engineers.

[1] Office space is expensive, but not that expensive relative to an engineer's salary. The going rate for class A space in Manhattan is about $70/square foot per year. That puts a 10x10 office (assuming 85% usable space) at about $8,000 per year + build-out + maintenance.

[2] Apple's new spaceship building (in the middle of a faceless suburb) will cost $5 billion and have 2.8 million square feet of space. One World Trade Center (in downtown Manhattan) will cost $3.9 billion and have over 3 million square feet of class A office space. A lower-profile project, the New York Times building in Midtown West, was constructed for $850 million and has 1.5 million square feet.

Apparently Google spent almost $2 billion on a squat 18-story structure in Manhattan with an over-abundance of depressing window-less interior spaces... I'm going to assume it was the difficulty of getting 2.9 million square feet in one place rather than just bad taste.

EDIT: I'm not saying Apple's offices are open plan. I have no idea what Apple's setup is. I'm pointing out that companies are certainly willing to spend a lot of money on these big suburban office parks, multiples of what it would cost to just buy a couple of skyscrapers in SF. Thus, cost does not seem to be the motivating factor (except maybe in a penny-wise pound-foolish sort of way).

Re:Research: Cubicles Are the Absolute Worst by jlgreco on Monday November 18, 2013 @05:26PM (#6757624)
Keeping programmers in cubicles or in open office space prevents them from drawing parallels between themselves an other sorts of professionals that command similar or greater salaries.

As long as corporate programmers think of themselves as socially below doctors, lawyers, professors (who tend to get paid less!), accountants, etc, then management can continue to treat them poorly ("Everyone should be working late into the evening this month, but don't worry, free pizza!" ...I doubt those sort of tricks would work well in other professions.)

Re:Research: Cubicles Are the Absolute Worst by itafroma on Monday November 18, 2013 @04:36PM (#6757240)
> I have no idea why tech companies would pay engineers gobs of money, spend gobs of money on huge office campuses, then inflict open plan or cubicles on said engineers.

It's largely due to the conventional wisdom created in the 90s by Microsoft's Jim McCarthy known as "21 Rules of Thumb for Shipping Great Software on Time".[1] Rule 6 (or 8 in his later talks[2]) is "beware of a guy in a room":

> Specialist developers who lock themselves away in a room, going dark for long stretches, are anathema to shipping great software on time. Without regard to their individual brilliance, before investing a developer with a significant assignment, it is essential that they understand and agree with the type of development program you intend to run. They must be capable of performing on a team, making their work visible in modest increments and subjecting it to scrutiny as it matures. Some people find this intolerable, and though there is a role for people of this disposition in the software world, it is not as part of a team devoted to shipping great software on time.

[1]: http://blogs.msdn.com/b/david_gristwood/archive/2004/06/24/1...

[2]: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oY6BCHqEbyc

Re:Research: Cubicles Are the Absolute Worst by abalone on Monday November 18, 2013 @04:44PM (#6757294)
I remember that one. It doesn't literally mean "don't give engineers rooms." It means there should be regular public (to the team) milestones that force engineers to show their work.

The room thing just comes from the visual of a rockstar coder coming into work and locking himself in his office and saying don't worry, everything's fine, trust me I'll have it done in time. Beware of that.

Re:Research: Cubicles Are the Absolute Worst by itafroma on Monday November 18, 2013 @04:47PM (#6757321)
> It means there should be regular public (to the team) milestones that force engineers to show their work.

While that is part of the underlying point, "beware of a guy in a room" is very much "don't stick a guy in a room by himself and let him do his thing" (he emphasizes it more in the video I linked to). The larger, more figurative point about having regular, public milestones is rule 4, "don't go dark", of which he claims rule 6 is a special case.

Re:Research: Cubicles Are the Absolute Worst by abalone on Monday November 18, 2013 @09:01PM (#6758749)
Not to be pedantic but he's making a point about "preeminent developer types" not office space. Specifically don't bet the schedule on one rockstar developer's word alone.

It really has little to do with the physical office space configuration. This problem could happen in open plans too, assuming a sufficiently complex project that can't be assessed by merely glancing over their shoulder.

Re:Research: Cubicles Are the Absolute Worst by slm_HN on Monday November 18, 2013 @05:26PM (#6757620)
I feel strongly that 99% of the people who are responsible for making this decision have no idea who "Microsoft's Jim McCarthy" is, other than maybe Jenny McCarthy's husband.
Re:Research: Cubicles Are the Absolute Worst by itafroma on Monday November 18, 2013 @05:41PM (#6757758)
I agree that it is now conventional wisdom, passed down from manager to manager to entrepreneur to entrepreneur without regard from whence it came. But Jim McCarthy is somewhat of a legend, particularly in Microsoft circles, having led the team that created Visual C++ and helping to form the basis for the Microsoft Solutions Framework. Jenny McCarthy doesn't have a husband, and Jim McCarthy's spouse is Michele McCarthy.
Re:Research: Cubicles Are the Absolute Worst by rayiner on Monday November 18, 2013 @06:50PM (#6758182)
Isn't Jenny McCarthy married to Jim Carey.
Re:Research: Cubicles Are the Absolute Worst by 001sky on Monday November 18, 2013 @04:14PM (#6757076)
I have no idea why tech companies would pay engineers gobs of money, spend gobs of money on huge office campuses, then inflict open plan or cubicles on said engineers.

A firm is a hierarchy, and this is a form of social control.

Re:Research: Cubicles Are the Absolute Worst by humanrebar on Monday November 18, 2013 @04:34PM (#6757225)
As a counterpoint, there are companies that have open floor plans or cubes for everyone all the way up to the C*Os.
Re:Research: Cubicles Are the Absolute Worst by ArbitraryLimits on Monday November 18, 2013 @06:03PM (#6757950)
Yeah, but the CEO always ends up commandeering the nicest conference room as his de facto office, or else he's always on the road.
Re:Research: Cubicles Are the Absolute Worst by rhizome on Tuesday November 19, 2013 @04:10PM (#6764495)
Yes, there "are" companies where the CxOs are out on the floor like everybody else, but I've only seen it once and that was when we were ~5ppl doing an officeshare.
Re:Research: Cubicles Are the Absolute Worst by throwaway1460 on Monday November 18, 2013 @04:31PM (#6757212)

    > Apple's new spaceship building (in the middle of a faceless suburb)
    > will cost $5 billion and have 2.8 million square feet of space
… that no employee below VP level can afford to live near. It's OK, though; Apple doesn't have to pay them for the tenth of their lives they waste commuting.

And above the entrance these words appear: “My name is Jobs, CEO of CEOs: Look on my works, ye Mighty, and despair.”

Re:Research: Cubicles Are the Absolute Worst by mwfunk on Monday November 18, 2013 @05:21PM (#6757583)
They can absolutely afford to live near it. Based on my own anecdotal experience at least, the people who work for the big tech companies in the South Bay with the long commutes are generally the ones who choose to have long commutes so they can work in the South Bay but live in SF. If affordability were their concern, they could save a ton of money by just living nearby in Sunnyvale or Campbell or wherever.

I also know people who work for those same companies who have long commutes for affordability reasons, but they seem to be the exceptions rather than the rule. Even in their case, it's usually for reasons other than there's just no way they can afford to live in the South Bay. More often, it's because they are determined to have a really big house with a really big yard and are unwilling to concede on that (such a thing is quite a luxury in the South Bay). Even then, they're accepting the commute for because they want to, not because they have to. It really sucks that housing is that ridiculous in the Bay Area, but it's not like any of these huge companies are going to pick up and leave and build their giant new campus out in the middle of the desert or something.

Re:Research: Cubicles Are the Absolute Worst by throwaway1460 on Monday November 18, 2013 @05:44PM (#6757794)

  > not like any of these huge companies are going to pick up and leave and
  > build their giant new campus out in the middle of the desert or something.
Or something.

Typically a programmer's daily work product can be moved half way around the world in a fraction of a second, for a fraction of a cent.

Perhaps there should be an addition to Latency numbers every programmer should know:

  Programmer drives to work .... 3,000,000,000,000 ns
Re:Research: Cubicles Are the Absolute Worst by objclxt on Monday November 18, 2013 @04:47PM (#6757316)
I don't think it's the affordability that's the problem - or rather, I know plenty of people at Google / Facebook / Apple / any other company in the valley who make the choice to commute not because of any cost saving, but because they don't want to live somewhere with very little going on socially and pretty much constant need for a car.
Re:Research: Cubicles Are the Absolute Worst by strlen on Monday November 18, 2013 @09:10PM (#6758801)
> … that no employee below VP level can afford to live near.

San Jose, Santa Clara, Campbell, and even parts of Cupertino and Sunnyvale are far more affordable than SF. This is especially so for couples and families.

(Suburbia is a far cry from SF in terms of culture, obviously, but that's a different topic)

Re:Research: Cubicles Are the Absolute Worst by abalone on Monday November 18, 2013 @04:42PM (#6757280)
Do you actually know if the new Apple building is open plan? I believe they currently have offices.

Pixar, the previous Jobs-designed office building, gives employees a lot of control over their personal spaces. Designers actually get their own mini house. (Kind of like an Ikea showroom.) They have lounge-like common spaces you can work/meet in too.

Re:Research: Cubicles Are the Absolute Worst by sgsz101 on Monday November 18, 2013 @04:31PM (#6757208)
...your point still stands, but with regards to Apple - many engineers actually have offices, rather than cubicles or open-plan. You can be pretty sure they'll be staying at the new campus, or there would be an outright revolt.
Re:Research: Cubicles Are the Absolute Worst by ArbitraryLimits on Monday November 18, 2013 @05:55PM (#6757884)
> I have no idea why tech companies would pay engineers gobs of money,[1] spend gobs of money on huge office campuses,[2] then inflict open plan or cubicles on said engineers

It's because cubicles can be depreciated as furniture, over 10 (or 7, I've never been clear on the difference) years, whereas internal walls and doors get depreciated as real estate over a 27.5 year schedule. The CFO has to do something.

http://discuss.joelonsoftware.com/default.asp?joel.3.318767....