Re:Bayes and Big Data: The Consensus Monte Carlo Algorithm
by ColinWright on Monday November 18, 2013 @10:21AM
(#6754682)
I really wish you'd said in the first instance that it appeared that the paper wasn't really saying anything new, and left out the implication that it's getting more air purely because it's from Google.
Not least, you might be wrong. It might be getting more air not because it's from Google, but simply because it has more visibilty in general. My feeling is that other, perhaps more scholarly, and perhaps more in-depth articles don't see the light of day simply because they are in more obscure places. You can help by pointing at other sources of similar material, and explaining why they are potentially of more value.
A single line of "It's by a Googler" was unenlightening, and to me came off as pure snark.
Not least, you might be wrong. It might be getting more air not because it's from Google, but simply because it has more visibilty in general. My feeling is that other, perhaps more scholarly, and perhaps more in-depth articles don't see the light of day simply because they are in more obscure places. You can help by pointing at other sources of similar material, and explaining why they are potentially of more value.
A single line of "It's by a Googler" was unenlightening, and to me came off as pure snark.